Time Off in Lieu: Employer Legal Guide

Time off in lieu (TOIL) is widely used across UK workplaces to manage peaks in operational demand, reduce overtime costs and support flexible working arrangements. When administered properly, TOIL can provide employees with valued additional time away from work and help employers manage staffing levels more effectively. When administered poorly, TOIL becomes a significant compliance risk, leading to unlawful deduction of wages claims, inconsistent treatment across teams and disputes about when accrued time can be taken. Poorly designed TOIL practices can also put employers at risk of breaching the Working Time Regulations and the National Minimum Wage rules if overall pay and working hours are not monitored carefully.

This article examines TOIL from an employer and HR perspective, providing a comprehensive overview of the legal, practical and procedural considerations involved in offering time off instead of overtime pay. Because TOIL is not a statutory entitlement, employers must rely on robust contractual provisions and carefully drafted policies to ensure the approach is lawful and consistently applied. HR teams must also ensure that TOIL practices align with the Working Time Regulations, particularly around maximum weekly working hours and rest entitlements, and do not reduce pay below the relevant National Minimum Wage for the pay reference period. TOIL arrangements cannot lawfully be used to replace or reduce statutory annual leave or minimum daily and weekly rest periods.

What this article is about:
This article explains how TOIL works, the legal framework employers must operate within, and the essential elements of an effective TOIL policy. It covers the rules on authorising extra hours, calculating TOIL accurately, administering TOIL fairly, managing expiry periods and limits, and addressing pay issues that arise when TOIL cannot be taken. It also examines TOIL risks at termination of employment, including where TOIL terms are unclear or silent and payment will often be required for accrued time, how TOIL interacts with part-time and irregular-hours workers, and the claims employees may bring if TOIL is mishandled. This guide is designed to give HR professionals and business owners the clarity needed to implement and manage TOIL in a legally compliant and operationally effective way.

Section A: Legal framework for TOIL

Time off in lieu operates entirely as a contractual mechanism. Because UK employment law does not provide a statutory right to TOIL, employers must ensure their arrangements are written, communicated and implemented in a way that provides clarity about entitlement and protects the organisation from pay-related claims. This section examines the legal foundation of TOIL and sets out the minimum requirements HR teams should establish before TOIL can be offered safely and consistently. TOIL always operates in addition to statutory annual leave and minimum daily and weekly rest periods and cannot be used to reduce or replace those statutory entitlements.

1. TOIL and UK employment law

TOIL is not recognised as a standalone statutory right under the Employment Rights Act 1996 or the Working Time Regulations 1998 (WTR). Employees cannot demand TOIL unless their contract or workplace policy expressly states that TOIL is available. Where no TOIL provision exists, employees are normally entitled to be paid for authorised overtime in accordance with their contract.

Even with a TOIL policy in place, employers must still comply with the WTR. Any additional hours worked count towards the employee’s working time, which means employers must ensure workers do not exceed the 48-hour weekly limit unless an opt-out is in place. Night working limits, daily and weekly rest periods, and paid annual leave entitlements remain unaffected by TOIL arrangements. TOIL cannot be used to reduce or replace statutory rest or holiday entitlements, and employers must still ensure that overall pay does not fall below the applicable National Minimum Wage rate over the relevant pay reference period.

2. Contractual terms and policies

A written contractual provision or staff handbook policy is critical to defining how TOIL operates. Without clear terms, TOIL arrangements become vulnerable to challenge, especially if employees believe they are being denied pay or are treated inconsistently.

A well-drafted TOIL clause should specify:

• when TOIL can be offered instead of overtime pay
• the rate of TOIL accrual (usually hour-for-hour unless otherwise agreed)
• the process for authorising additional hours
• how TOIL is recorded and approved
• the timeframe within which TOIL must be taken
• whether unused TOIL expires
• the approach to TOIL balance payments when employment ends

These terms protect the employer from disputes and ensure managers follow a consistent process. A discretionary, undocumented approach increases the likelihood of unlawful deduction claims, particularly where accrued TOIL is later denied or time off is refused without fair justification.

3. When TOIL is appropriate

TOIL is typically used where overtime needs fluctuate throughout the year or where employers want to avoid a regular overtime pay culture. It is most effective where work patterns allow employees to take equivalent time off during quieter periods.

TOIL should only be used when:

• the additional hours have been expressly authorised
• the employee has agreed to receive TOIL instead of payment
• the arrangement does not breach working time limits or create health and safety risks
• the employer can accommodate the time off within reasonable timescales

Employers cannot unilaterally impose TOIL in place of overtime pay unless the employee’s contract already provides for this. Equally, employees cannot insist on TOIL if their contract entitles them to overtime pay. HR must ensure managers understand the contractual rights so decisions remain lawful and consistent.

Section Summary:
TOIL is a contractual mechanism that must be underpinned by clear written terms to avoid pay disputes and ensure compliance with the Working Time Regulations. Employers must specify how TOIL accrues, how it is authorised, the limits on when it can be taken, and the implications for payment at termination. With the legal framework correctly established, organisations can administer TOIL in a way that is both flexible and lawful while respecting statutory rest, holiday and minimum wage obligations.

Section B: Managing and recording TOIL

Effective management of time off in lieu depends on accurate authorisation, transparent calculation and reliable recordkeeping. Poor administration exposes employers to legal risk, including unlawful deduction from wages claims and disputes about working time. HR professionals must ensure that TOIL systems are consistent across teams and aligned with the organisation’s contractual and policy framework. Employers must also monitor overall working hours and pay to ensure compliance with the Working Time Regulations and National Minimum Wage legislation.

1. Authorising extra hours

TOIL arrangements should begin with clear authorisation of the additional hours worked. Managers must not allow employees to accrue TOIL informally or retrospectively, as this creates uncertainty about entitlement and may lead to disagreements about whether overtime was required. Employers should set out who can approve TOIL-eligible hours and the criteria for granting approval, such as operational need or project deadlines.

Unauthorised overtime presents a particular challenge. If employees work beyond their contracted hours without permission, the organisation may still be legally required to pay for the time worked where it knew, or reasonably ought to have known, that those hours were being worked. However, the employer is not obliged to grant TOIL unless doing so is consistent with its policy. HR should therefore communicate the authorisation requirements clearly and ensure employees understand that TOIL can only accrue when overtime has been sanctioned in advance, while also reminding managers that they cannot avoid wage liability simply by refusing to acknowledge regularly worked extra hours.

2. Calculating TOIL accurately

Once additional hours are approved, employers must ensure the calculation of TOIL is consistent with the organisation’s policy. Most employers use a time-for-time model, where each hour worked beyond contractual hours results in one hour of TOIL. Some roles, particularly those involving unsocial hours or intensive operational periods, may justify enhanced accrual, although this must be clearly defined in the contract or policy.

Accurate calculation also requires attention to:

• rounding practices
• part-hours or split shifts
• paid breaks or rest periods
• the impact of travel time where applicable

Errors in calculation often lead to disputes about worker entitlements and can trigger allegations of unlawful deductions. HR must maintain oversight of TOIL administration to ensure managers follow the policy consistently and that arrangements do not result in average pay falling below the National Minimum Wage over the relevant pay reference period.

3. Recordkeeping and audit trails

A reliable recordkeeping system is essential for TOIL compliance. Employers should use timesheets, digital timekeeping platforms or HR systems capable of tracking overtime hours and TOIL balances. These records must provide a clear audit trail that shows:

• the hours authorised
• when they were worked
• the TOIL accrued
• when the TOIL was taken
• any expired or lapsed balances

Transparent records help resolve disputes quickly and demonstrate lawful practice if the organisation faces an employment tribunal claim or regulatory inspection. They also support workforce planning by giving HR visibility over patterns of overtime and accrued TOIL across the organisation, allowing emerging risks around excessive working hours, rest compliance and minimum wage exposure to be identified early.

Section Summary:
TOIL must be managed with clear authorisation, accurate calculation and robust recordkeeping. Employers who allow informal or inconsistent practices expose themselves to legal risk and potential pay disputes. A structured approach ensures employees know when TOIL can be accrued, how it is calculated, and how their entitlement will be recorded and managed, while supporting compliance with working time and minimum wage requirements.

Section C: Taking TOIL and limits

Once TOIL has been accrued, employers must manage how and when it is taken in a way that supports operational needs while remaining fair and legally compliant. Clear rules around requesting, approving and using TOIL reduce misunderstandings and prevent the build-up of excessive TOIL balances that can disrupt workforce planning. Employers must also ensure that arrangements for taking TOIL operate alongside, and not in place of, statutory annual leave and minimum rest entitlements under the Working Time Regulations.

1. Requesting and approving TOIL

Employees should follow a formal process when requesting to take TOIL. Employers should require requests to be submitted in advance, unless exceptional circumstances apply, and decisions should be made within a reasonable timeframe. Managers must balance the employee’s preference for time off with business requirements, including staffing levels, peak workload periods and service delivery obligations.

While employers can refuse a TOIL request on reasonable business grounds, they must not apply the refusal process inconsistently or in a way that undermines the TOIL scheme. Decisions should be recorded to ensure transparency, and HR should monitor patterns of approval or refusal to avoid discriminatory or unfair practice.

2. Expiry rules, backlogs and capping

TOIL schemes work best where there are clear rules governing how long TOIL can remain unused. Employers commonly set expiry periods such as:

• TOIL must be taken within a specified number of weeks or months
• TOIL that is not used within the timeframe is forfeited

Alternatively, employers may allow carry-over into the next leave cycle but place a cap on the maximum TOIL balance an employee can hold at any one time. These rules help prevent long-term TOIL backlogs that can become financially or operationally burdensome.

Whatever approach is taken, the rules must be clearly set out in writing. If TOIL expires, employers must ensure employees were reasonably able to take the TOIL before the deadline. Failure to give employees a genuine opportunity to take TOIL may undermine expiry provisions and increase legal risk, particularly if employees argue that forfeiture is being used to avoid paying for hours that have already been worked.

3. TOIL during busy periods

Organisations with fluctuating workloads may find TOIL particularly challenging to administer during peak periods. HR should anticipate seasonal or cyclical demand and ensure managers plan ahead to provide employees with reasonable opportunities to use TOIL.

Employers must also continue to comply with the Working Time Regulations. Employees taking TOIL cannot be required to forego statutory rest periods, nor can TOIL be used to mask unsafe or excessive working hours. A well-planned TOIL system supports health and safety by ensuring employees have adequate rest following periods of heavy workload and by preventing a culture of persistent overtime that might compromise wellbeing.

Section Summary:
Employers must manage TOIL usage through a structured system of requests, approvals and limits. Clear expiry or capping rules prevent large TOIL backlogs, and a consistent approach reduces the risk of disputes. Planning ahead is vital to ensure employees can take TOIL without breaching working time obligations, undermining statutory rest and holiday entitlements, or compromising operational requirements.

Section D: TOIL and pay issues

Time off in lieu affects pay, contractual entitlements and termination payments, making it critical for HR teams to understand the legal boundaries. Employers must ensure that TOIL practices do not violate the rules on wages, minimum pay, or fair treatment. Mismanaging TOIL can lead to costly disputes, including unlawful deduction of wages claims and grievances over inconsistent pay outcomes.

1. When TOIL must be paid

Although TOIL is intended to replace overtime pay, there are circumstances where employers must pay for accrued hours. The most common situation is termination of employment. If an employee leaves with a positive TOIL balance, and the employer’s policy or contract states that TOIL should be paid on departure, the employer must make the payment in the final wage. Where TOIL terms are unclear or silent, there is a significant risk that withholding payment for accrued TOIL will be treated as a breach of contract or an unlawful deduction, particularly if the employer cannot demonstrate that the employee had a genuine and reasonable opportunity to take the time off.

Employers should also consider payment where operational constraints consistently prevent employees from using TOIL within the policy’s timeframe. Forcing TOIL to expire without offering time off can create arguments that the employer is avoiding wage liability unfairly. HR should monitor TOIL balances to ensure employees are not accumulating entitlement without access to time off and that decisions around payment or forfeiture do not result in pay falling below the National Minimum Wage for the relevant pay reference period.

2. TOIL for part-time and shift workers

TOIL practices must account for diverse working patterns. Part-time staff should accrue TOIL proportionately to their contracted hours. For shift workers or employees with irregular patterns, TOIL calculations may need to reflect the specific duration and nature of the shift worked.

Employers must ensure TOIL is administered consistently across full-time and part-time employees to avoid discrimination claims. A well-drafted policy explains how TOIL accrues for different worker types and how TOIL requests are prioritised in environments with complex rotas. Where hourly rates differ, employers must also ensure that the use of TOIL does not distort overall pay in a way that risks breaching minimum wage obligations.

3. Disputes, unlawful deduction risks and enforcement

The most common legal risk associated with TOIL is unlawful deduction from wages. This occurs when an employer fails to pay an employee the wages they are entitled to under their contract. TOIL disputes often arise when:

• extra hours were worked but not properly authorised
• the employee believes they earned TOIL that the employer denies
• the employer refuses payment for unused TOIL without contractual justification
• expiry rules were applied unfairly or inconsistently

To mitigate risk, employers must maintain transparent TOIL records, communicate policy rules clearly, and ensure managers apply them consistently. HR should also intervene early in disputes to prevent escalation. Formal grievances or tribunal claims may allege breach of contract, unlawful deduction, or unfair treatment, and tribunals will look closely at whether the employer’s documentation, recordkeeping and practices reflect what employees were told about how TOIL would operate in practice.

Section Summary:
TOIL administration must align with wage laws, contractual terms and fair treatment principles. Employers must pay TOIL in certain circumstances, particularly at termination or where employees have not had a real opportunity to take accrued time off, and must ensure part-time and shift workers are treated consistently. Clear records and transparent policies are essential to defending against TOIL-related pay disputes and to maintaining compliance with minimum wage legislation.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

Is TOIL a legal requirement?

No. Time off in lieu is not a statutory right. It is a contractual mechanism that employers may choose to offer. Employees can only accrue TOIL where their contract or workplace policy allows it.

Can an employer insist on TOIL instead of overtime pay?

Only if the employee’s contract or the organisation’s policies clearly permit TOIL to be given instead of payment. Without express agreement, employees are usually entitled to receive pay for overtime worked, and employers must also ensure that overall pay does not fall below the applicable National Minimum Wage.

How long can TOIL be carried over?

This depends entirely on the employer’s policy. Many organisations set limits or expiry dates. Any expiry rule must give employees a reasonable opportunity to use their TOIL, otherwise it becomes vulnerable to challenge and may be viewed as an attempt to avoid paying for hours already worked.

Does TOIL count as working time?

The hours worked to earn TOIL count as working time under the Working Time Regulations. The TOIL taken does not reduce statutory holiday or rest entitlements, which must still be provided in full.

What happens to TOIL when employment ends?

If the employee leaves with accrued TOIL, employers may need to pay for the outstanding hours. Whether payment is mandatory depends on the contract and on whether the employee was reasonably able to take the time off before leaving. Where TOIL terms are unclear or silent, there is a significant risk that withholding payment will be treated as a breach of contract or an unlawful deduction.

Can zero-hours or irregular-hours staff accrue TOIL?

Yes, provided the organisation’s policy allows it. TOIL must be calculated consistently and reflect the actual hours worked. Employers must avoid discriminatory or inconsistent practices and ensure that arrangements do not result in average pay falling below the National Minimum Wage over the relevant pay reference period.

Conclusion

Time off in lieu can be an effective tool for managing overtime and supporting flexible work patterns, but only when underpinned by clear contractual terms and consistent HR oversight. Employers must establish transparent rules governing when TOIL can be earned, how it accrues, and how it should be taken. Without this clarity, TOIL becomes a source of legal and operational risk, particularly where pay disputes arise or where employees claim unlawful deductions, breaches of minimum wage law or a failure to honour what was promised in policy documents.

Effective TOIL administration requires proactive management. Employers should monitor accruals, ensure employees can take TOIL within policy limits, and maintain reliable records to evidence compliance. HR teams play a central role in educating managers, ensuring fairness across the workforce, and intervening early where disputes emerge. They must also keep TOIL practices under review to ensure continued alignment with the Working Time Regulations and National Minimum Wage requirements.

By combining strong contractual foundations with fair and consistent practice, organisations can use TOIL to balance operational pressures and employee wellbeing while remaining fully compliant with UK employment law. A well-governed TOIL scheme supports engagement and flexibility without exposing the business to unnecessary legal or financial risk.

Glossary

Useful links