Tax on Commission Pay: Employer Guide UK

Commission remains a central component of remuneration strategies for UK employers, particularly in sales-driven environments or roles where performance incentives determine productivity. Although widely used, commission arrangements create specific tax, payroll and compliance risks that are often underestimated. HMRC expects employers to operate PAYE and National Insurance correctly on all commission, including Class 1 NICs on cash payments and Class 1A NICs on certain non-cash commission or incentive awards, yet the variable and sometimes irregular nature of commission makes this more complex in practice.

What this article is about:
This article provides a detailed, employer-focused analysis of the UK tax rules that apply to commission pay. It examines how commission is treated as taxable earnings, how PAYE and NICs must be operated, common payroll errors, compliance duties, and the consequences of mis-taxing commission structures. It also explains how to design legally robust commission schemes, manage clawbacks, and reduce HMRC risk through accurate reporting and documentation, including where commission is provided in non-cash form and attracts Class 1A NICs.

Commission operates under the same statutory framework as other forms of taxable employment income under the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003. However, its fluctuating nature means employers must understand how earnings periods, Real Time Information (RTI) reporting, holiday pay calculations, deductions, repayments and, where relevant, salary sacrifice arrangements interact with the tax system. Errors commonly arise where commission is irregular, paid late, reclaimed, or structured without reference to tax rules, or where employers assume that non-cash awards fall outside PAYE/NIC obligations.

Employers must also ensure that contractual documentation is aligned to tax requirements. A commission plan that appears commercially sound can still expose a business to HMRC challenge if it operates as disguised remuneration, creates an unlawful net-to-gross arrangement where the employer undertakes to meet the employee’s tax liability, or fails to specify when commission is earned versus due. Similarly, where commission interacts with holiday pay or clawback provisions, employers must apply specific legislative and case law principles to avoid incorrect taxation, breaches of the National Minimum Wage rules in the context of deductions, or unlawful deduction claims under the Employment Rights Act 1996.

This guide equips HR professionals, payroll teams and business owners with a full, systematic understanding of how commission is taxed in the UK. The focus is on helping employers meet their PAYE and NIC obligations (including in relation to non-cash awards and Class 1A NICs), design sustainable commission schemes and avoid the compliance pitfalls that frequently arise with variable remuneration and complex incentive arrangements.

Section A: Understanding Commission as Taxable Income

Commission is treated as taxable employment income when paid to an employee in connection with their work. For employers, the starting point is the statutory definition of “earnings” under the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 (ITEPA), which brings commission within the scope of PAYE regardless of how frequently it is paid, how predictable it is, or whether it is tied to individual or company performance. Misunderstanding this principle is a common cause of PAYE errors, particularly where commission is treated informally or managed outside the payroll system.

This section explains how commission is defined for tax purposes, when tax liability arises, how the “made available” tax point operates, and how HMRC distinguishes commission from bonus payments.

1. What Counts as Commission for Tax Purposes

Commission is any payment, whether regular or irregular, made as a reward for work carried out. Under ITEPA, it is classified as “earnings” because it arises from the employment relationship. This includes payments calculated by reference to:

• individual sales or revenue
• team or departmental performance
• new accounts, leads or contracts generated
• margin-based or profit-linked outputs
• agreed targets or quotas

Commission may be paid weekly, monthly, quarterly or annually. The frequency does not alter its tax classification. Non-cash commission (such as vouchers, gift cards or other incentive awards) is also taxable and may attract Class 1A NICs depending on the nature of the award and how it is provided. Where employers use accelerators or multipliers within a commission plan, the entire amount remains taxable as employment earnings.

2. When Commission is Taxable

Commission becomes taxable when it is paid or “made available” to the employee, even if the commission relates to performance from an earlier period. “Made available” includes situations where an employee has an unconditional right to the income and could draw on it if they chose, even if payment has been administratively delayed.

The tax point may arise earlier than physical payment if contractual wording states commission is “earned” or “due” upon completion of a specific activity, such as closing a sale. Poorly drafted commission plans can therefore create unintended tax timing issues.

Clawbacks, cancellations or overpayments also affect tax treatment. Where an employee repays previously taxed commission, the repayment may qualify as negative earnings under s.128 ITEPA. Employers should process relief through payroll in the same tax year where possible. If this cannot be done, the employee may need to claim relief directly from HMRC after year-end.

3. Commission vs Bonus: Tax Treatment Differences

HMRC generally treats both commission and bonuses as taxable earnings. However, classification matters for contractual interpretation, enforceability, holiday pay calculations and clawback application.

Commission is directly linked to measurable performance, whereas bonuses may depend on discretionary company or individual performance factors. HMRC reviews the substance of the payment, not the label. A payment called a bonus may still be taxed as commission if it operates on a formula basis, and vice versa.

Section A Summary

Commission is always taxable where it arises from employment. Employers must correctly identify when commission is earned, due and “made available”, ensure accurate tax timing, and understand the distinction between commission and bonuses. Proper classification supports PAYE accuracy, reduces risk of dispute and ensures compliance during HMRC reviews.

Section B: PAYE & National Insurance on Commission Pay

Commission is subject to PAYE income tax and Class 1 National Insurance contributions (NICs) in the same way as basic salary. Because commission is often irregular, retrospective or contingent on sales cycles, employers must apply PAYE rules correctly to avoid distorted tax codes, incorrect reporting or NIC miscalculations. This section explains how PAYE and NICs operate for commission, the impact of separate payroll runs, the treatment of non-cash commission subject to Class 1A NICs, and the employment status issues that may arise.

1. PAYE Treatment of Commission

Employers must deduct PAYE on commission at the point of payment or when it is “made available”, regardless of when the underlying performance occurred. If commission is paid through regular payroll, PAYE is calculated using the employee’s cumulative tax code. Where commission is paid in an off-cycle run, PAYE must still be operated fully using the employee’s current code.

Commission is a “supplementary payment” under PAYE rules, meaning:

• it must be reported under RTI on or before the payment date
• it may temporarily push employees into higher tax bands within the pay period
• it interacts with cumulative codes unless HMRC has issued a non-cumulative (week 1/month 1) code

Employers must not apply emergency, basic rate, or non-cumulative codes unless HMRC has formally issued them. Applying an incorrect code is a common compliance failure identified during HMRC audits.

2. NICs on Commission

All cash commission payments are subject to Class 1 employee and employer NICs. NICs are calculated based on the earnings period in which the payment is made, even if the commission relates to work carried out earlier.

Key principles include:

• earnings periods cannot be averaged to reduce NIC liability
• fluctuating commission may push earnings above the Upper Earnings Limit (UEL)
• separate commission runs do not create new earnings periods unless a full calendar month separates them

Non-cash commission or incentive rewards—such as vouchers, gift cards or certain benefits—may attract Class 1A NICs and must be reported on form P11D(b). Payroll, HR and finance teams must ensure all incentive awards are correctly assessed for their NIC category.

3. Commission in Employment Status Context

Commission interacts closely with employment status assessments. Employers must determine whether the individual receiving commission is genuinely self-employed, an agency worker, or an employee whose commission requires full PAYE treatment.

Key scenarios include:

• Self-employed commission agents: genuine agents may receive commission gross, but only if their working arrangements support true self-employment.
• Agency workers: commission paid by agencies or end-clients may fall within the Agency Workers Regulations 2010 and must be taxed via the agency’s payroll.
• PSC contractors (IR35): where a personal service company receives commission linked to work similar to employment, the fee-payer may be required to apply PAYE under IR35.

HMRC frequently reviews commission-based arrangements during status audits, especially where variable pay could mask an employment relationship or where commission is partly paid outside payroll.

Section B Summary

Commission must be taxed in full under PAYE and NICs, including Class 1A NICs where non-cash rewards are provided. Employers should avoid incorrect tax codes, ensure accurate RTI submissions, and assess employment status carefully. Fluctuating earnings, off-cycle payments and hybrid commission arrangements often trigger HMRC scrutiny, making precise payroll handling essential.

Section C: Structuring Commission Schemes Tax-Compliantly

Commission schemes normally originate from commercial objectives, yet without deliberate tax and employment law alignment they can create PAYE errors, unlawful deductions, holiday pay underpayments and disguised remuneration risk. Employers must ensure that scheme rules are drafted clearly, processed consistently through payroll and fully compliant with the Working Time Regulations, ITEPA 2003 and the Employment Rights Act 1996. This section explains how to design tax-compliant commission schemes, manage holiday pay correctly, and apply clawback provisions lawfully while safeguarding National Minimum Wage compliance.

1. Designing Tax-Efficient Commission Structures

Commission is fully taxable, but employers can reduce risk by drafting schemes carefully and ensuring they align with PAYE and NIC rules. HMRC treats any financial reward arising from employment as “earnings”, meaning attempts to route commission payments through third parties, offshore entities or informal arrangements may be treated as disguised remuneration.

To design compliant schemes, employers should:

• define clearly when commission is earned, due and payable
• avoid net-to-gross arrangements unless correctly grossed-up under ITEPA s.203
• ensure rules for advances, drawdowns and deficit recovery are explicit
• align commission periods with payroll cycles to avoid RTI discrepancies
• identify non-cash incentives that may attract Class 1A NICs
• avoid structuring commission advances as informal “loans” unless the rules on employment-related loans are followed

Drawdown or advance commission models require particular care. If advances exceed earnings, employers must ensure recovery terms are properly documented and lawfully enforceable. Incorrect categorisation of advances as non-taxable loans or failure to reconcile advances within payroll can create disguised remuneration exposure under Part 7A ITEPA.

2. Commission, Holiday Pay and Working Time Regulations

Case law on the Working Time Regulations (including Lock v British Gas and the Bear Scotland decisions) clarifies that commission must be included in holiday pay calculations where it is sufficiently regular or intrinsically linked to the work performed. Employers must therefore ensure that holiday pay reflects average commission during the statutory 52-week reference period.

Importantly, the obligation to include commission applies to the EU-derived 4 weeks of annual leave. The additional 1.6 weeks of statutory leave under UK law may be calculated differently, although many employers use a single, consistent method for administrative simplicity.

Holiday pay derived from commission is taxable and must be processed through payroll with full PAYE and NIC deductions. Incorrect calculations can result in unlawful deductions claims, breach of contract, and arrears stretching back multiple years in some circumstances.

3. Commission Clawbacks & Tax

Clawback provisions allow employers to reclaim commission when sales fall through, clients cancel, or employees leave before vesting conditions are met. Once commission has been taxed, any repayment by the employee may qualify as negative earnings under s.128 ITEPA, allowing tax relief.

Employers must ensure that:

• clawback clauses are contractually enforceable and clearly drafted
• repayments are processed through payroll where possible in the same tax year
• National Minimum Wage rules are not breached by clawback deductions
• deductions comply with the Employment Rights Act 1996
• employees are informed of how repayments will be handled for tax purposes

If clawbacks cannot be processed within the same tax year, the employee may need to claim relief directly from HMRC. Employers should communicate this requirement clearly to avoid disputes.

Section C Summary

A compliant commission scheme must integrate PAYE and NIC rules, Working Time Regulations, holiday pay case law, negative earnings provisions and the National Minimum Wage framework. Precision in scheme drafting and payroll processing reduces the risk of unlawful deductions, disguised remuneration issues, miscalculated holiday pay and HMRC challenge.

Section D: Common Employer Risks & HMRC Enforcement

Commission schemes often attract focused HMRC attention because they involve irregular payments, variable earnings periods, incentive structures and sometimes non-cash rewards. These elements increase the risk of PAYE, NIC and reporting failures, especially where scheme administration is inconsistent or supported by weak documentation. HMRC regularly inspects commission arrangements during employer compliance reviews. This section explains the main enforcement risks and the controls employers should implement.

1. HMRC Audit Triggers for Commission Schemes

HMRC has identifiable triggers when selecting employers for compliance review. Commission schemes often fall within these triggers due to their fluctuating nature and the potential for inconsistent or incomplete reporting.

Common audit triggers include:

• RTI inconsistencies or irregular reporting patterns
• large or seasonal spikes in earnings that do not align with payroll data
• commission routed through third parties, umbrella companies or offshore entities
• non-cash rewards unreported for PAYE or Class 1A NIC purposes
• advance commission models lacking clear repayment terms, raising disguised remuneration concerns
• salary sacrifice arrangements involving commission where documentation or tax treatment is incorrect

HMRC’s focus is on whether the commission is properly classified as taxable earnings and whether PAYE has been operated at the correct tax point. Schemes that appear obscure, discretionary in an inconsistent way, or insufficiently documented attract deeper investigation.

2. Compliance Failures

Commission systems frequently generate compliance risks where payroll, finance and HR teams are not aligned or where manual calculations drive scheme operation. The most common failures include:

• incorrect Class 1 NIC calculations on cash commission
• failure to apply Class 1A NICs to non-cash commission or incentive awards
• untaxed non-cash rewards such as vouchers or incentives arranged with third parties
• misclassification of workers receiving commission, especially where employment status assessments are unclear
• unlawful net-to-gross arrangements where employers absorb employee tax liabilities without correct gross-up procedures
• poor scheme documentation, making it difficult to demonstrate how or when commission was earned
• incorrect handling of salary sacrifice where employees sacrifice commission for pension contributions or other benefits

Commission routed via umbrella companies, agencies or offshore structures without proper oversight can trigger HMRC concerns about disguised remuneration, even where the employer had no intention of tax avoidance.

3. Best-Practice Internal Controls

A robust control environment is essential for managing tax and compliance risk in commission schemes. Employers should:

• map end-to-end processes from performance measurement to payroll deduction
• ensure all commission payments, including ad hoc or off-cycle payments, flow through payroll
• maintain clear audit trails documenting commission calculations and approvals
• align contractual conditions with PAYE/NIC rules and ensure these rules are applied consistently
• conduct periodic data checks to identify RTI inaccuracies, NIC errors or clawback issues
• monitor salary sacrifice arrangements to confirm correct application of PAYE and NIC rules

Regular internal reviews help ensure that commission schemes remain aligned with legal requirements and HMRC expectations. Payroll software must also be configured correctly for variable earnings, statutory payments and any commission linked to salary sacrifice or benefits in kind.

Section D Summary

Commission schemes carry elevated HMRC enforcement risk due to variability in earnings, the potential for inconsistent reporting, and the interaction with employment status, salary sacrifice and incentive awards. Strong internal controls, transparent documentation and accurate PAYE/NIC operation are essential to withstand HMRC scrutiny and maintain compliance.

FAQs

1. Is commission taxable in the UK?
Yes. Commission paid to an employee in connection with their work is taxable as employment income under ITEPA 2003. PAYE and Class 1 NICs apply at the point of payment or when the income is made available. Non-cash commission may attract Class 1A NICs.

2. How is tax calculated on irregular commission?
Irregular or ad hoc commission is taxed through PAYE using the employee’s current tax code. The payment may temporarily push the employee into a higher tax band for that period. Cumulative PAYE calculations will adjust automatically unless HMRC has issued a non-cumulative (week 1/month 1) code.

3. Does commission affect student loan or postgraduate loan deductions?
Yes. Commission counts as taxable income and therefore increases student loan and postgraduate loan deductions for the pay period in which it is paid.

4. Should commission be included in holiday pay calculations?
Yes, where the commission is sufficiently regular or intrinsically linked to the worker’s duties. Commission must be included in holiday pay calculations for the EU-derived 4 weeks of statutory leave using the correct 52-week reference period. PAYE and NICs apply to any holiday pay derived from commission.

5. Does National Insurance apply to commission payments?
Yes. Cash commission is subject to Class 1 NICs. Non-cash rewards may be subject to Class 1A NICs. Employers must use the correct earnings period and ensure all commission is processed through payroll or reported on P11D where appropriate.

6. How do commission clawbacks impact tax liability?
If taxed commission is later repaid by the employee, the repayment may qualify as negative earnings under s.128 ITEPA, allowing tax relief. Relief should be processed through payroll within the same tax year where possible. If not, the employee may claim relief directly from HMRC.

7. Are there special tax rules for non-cash commission?
Yes. Non-cash awards such as vouchers, gifts or incentive items remain taxable. They may require PAYE operation (if readily convertible assets) or P11D reporting with Class 1A NICs depending on how they are structured.

8. Can commission be paid gross to contractors?
Only where the contractor is genuinely self-employed or operating through a compliant PSC structure. If IR35 applies, the fee-payer must apply PAYE and NICs. Where IR35 applies, VAT cannot be charged on the labour element.

9. How should employers report one-off or ad hoc commission payments?
All commission payments must be reported under RTI on or before the payment date. Off-cycle payments do not exempt employers from PAYE or NIC obligations.

10. What triggers HMRC inquiries into commission schemes?
Common triggers include inconsistent RTI data, significant fluctuations in variable pay, unreported non-cash rewards, unclear clawback arrangements, incorrect salary sacrifice treatment and commission paid outside payroll processes.

Conclusion

Commission forms a vital part of many remuneration frameworks, but it introduces payroll, tax and compliance obligations that employers must manage with precision. HMRC classifies commission as taxable employment income, meaning PAYE and NICs must be applied correctly, including Class 1 NICs on cash payments and Class 1A NICs on certain non-cash awards. Errors tend to occur where commission fluctuates, where payments are processed outside normal payroll cycles, or where scheme rules are vague or inconsistently applied.

A compliant commission structure requires clear definitions of when commission is earned, due and payable, robust processes for calculating and approving commission, and accurate RTI submissions. Employers must also ensure that holiday pay reflects regular commission for the EU-derived 4 weeks of statutory leave and that clawback provisions are lawful, tax-correct and compliant with National Minimum Wage and Employment Rights Act 1996 rules.

By aligning commission schemes with statutory tax rules, holiday pay jurisprudence and HMRC guidance, employers can manage compliance risk effectively. Transparent documentation, coherent scheme design and consistent payroll operation enable commission to function as a productive incentive mechanism without creating PAYE errors, unlawful deductions or HMRC scrutiny.

Glossary

Useful Links