Withdrawing a Workplace Pension: HR Guidance

Most employees assume that withdrawing a workplace pension is a simple administrative step they can request from their employer. For HR professionals and business owners, the reality is more complex. Pension access is controlled by UK pensions legislation, tax rules and scheme-specific requirements, meaning withdrawals are tightly regulated and often misunderstood. Employers must also avoid giving regulated financial advice while still providing accurate, compliant information to employees who are exploring their pension options.

What this article is about: This article provides a comprehensive explanation of the rules governing the withdrawal of workplace pension savings. It clarifies when pension funds can legally be accessed, what employees can and cannot do, the employer’s role, and the compliance requirements under automatic enrolment legislation. The guide is designed for HR professionals and business owners who need to respond to employee pension withdrawal queries lawfully and confidently, without overstepping into regulated financial advice.

Employees frequently approach HR asking whether they can “withdraw” their pension, often due to financial distress, life changes or confusion about how pension access works. HR teams must therefore understand the distinction between accessing pension benefits, opting out of automatic enrolment, ceasing active membership and transferring pensions. The article also covers the tax consequences of taking pension benefits, how withdrawals interact with payroll, and how employers should manage re-enrolment obligations.

UK law delegates responsibility for workplace pension administration to pension providers, not employers, meaning HR’s role is limited to communication, signposting and statutory duties. However, HR must maintain compliance records, manage opt-outs within defined timeframes and handle sensitive employee conversations. This makes knowledge of the underlying legal framework vital for both legal compliance and risk management.

Section A: Legal Framework for Workplace Pension Withdrawals

Employees often ask whether they can “withdraw” their workplace pension, but this term is usually misunderstood. For HR professionals, the first step is to understand the legal framework that governs pension access, the distinction between pension withdrawal and opting out, and the employer’s obligations under automatic enrolment legislation. This section sets out the rules that determine when pension savings can be accessed, what options exist, and what employers must and must not do when supporting staff.

1. What “withdrawing a workplace pension” legally means

Employees generally mean one of three things when they talk about withdrawing their pension: accessing pension savings, opting out of the workplace pension scheme, or stopping future contributions. UK pensions law does not allow employees to simply withdraw contributions already made into a workplace pension as cash during employment unless they meet certain statutory criteria.

Workplace pensions operate under the Pensions Act 2008, the Finance Act 2004, the automatic enrolment regulations and scheme rules set by the provider. These collectively determine when funds can be released. For defined contribution schemes, contributions are invested and cannot be withdrawn until the minimum pension access age is reached, unless early access rules apply. In defined benefit schemes, withdrawals are governed by the scheme’s benefit structure and actuarial rules.

It is therefore not possible for an employee to request that the employer “cash out” pension contributions paid to date. Once paid, contributions are locked into the pension scheme until the individual qualifies for access under pension tax legislation or scheme-specific conditions. Where any refund is legally due (for example, on a valid opt-out within the statutory window), it is the scheme or provider that processes the refund in respect of both employer and employee contributions, not the employer directly unless the employer operates an in-house scheme on that basis.

2. When pension savings can legally be accessed

The normal minimum pension age (NMPA) currently stands at 55, rising to 57 from 2028. Employees cannot access their workplace pension savings before this age unless they meet strict early-access criteria set out in pensions and tax legislation and reflected in the scheme rules.

The main lawful access routes are:

• Minimum pension age access: From age 55 (57 from 2028), members can draw benefits through lump sums, drawdown or annuity purchase, subject to tax rules and scheme terms, even if they remain in employment.
• Ill-health retirement: Allowed when a medical professional confirms that the employee is incapable of continuing their job because of long-term illness, in line with the scheme’s ill-health criteria. Benefits may be actuarially reduced depending on the scheme.
• Serious ill-health lump sum: Permitted when life expectancy is less than 12 months and the scheme’s serious ill-health criteria are met. Following the abolition of the Lifetime Allowance, tax treatment now depends on the individual’s remaining Lump Sum and Death Benefit Allowance (LSDBA), with any excess taxed at the individual’s marginal rate.
• Small pots and trivial commutation: Limited conditions allow very small pension pots to be taken as cash under small-pot and trivial commutation rules, explained later in the article.

These rules apply regardless of the member’s employment status. Continuing to work does not prevent an employee from accessing pension savings if they meet the relevant statutory and scheme-based criteria.

3. Employer legal responsibilities

Employers do not grant or approve pension withdrawals. Access decisions are made by the scheme administrator or trustees in line with statutory pension and tax rules and the scheme’s governing documents. HR professionals should avoid giving any form of regulated financial advice, which is prohibited unless the employer is authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

The employer’s responsibilities include:

• Providing correct, factual information about the workplace pension scheme and automatic enrolment duties
• Signposting employees to the pension provider, MoneyHelper, Pension Wise (for eligible members) or regulated advisory sources
• Ensuring compliance with automatic enrolment and re-enrolment duties and maintaining accurate payroll and pension contribution records
• Avoiding any conduct that might be viewed as influencing an employee’s decision to stay in or leave the scheme, or to withdraw or transfer their pension

Employers must ensure communications remain factual and non-advisory. Expressing an opinion on whether an employee should withdraw, transfer or take a lump sum, or comparing the merits of different options, can fall within the FCA’s definition of regulated advice and should be avoided.

4. HR differentiation: withdrawal requests vs automatic enrolment opt-outs

Employees frequently confuse withdrawing pension contributions with opting out of the pension scheme. Under automatic enrolment law, employees have the right to opt out only within one month of being enrolled. Opt-out refunds are allowed only when the employee opts out within this statutory timeframe, and the refund of both employer and employee contributions is processed by the scheme in accordance with the regulations.

If an employee opts out after the first month or chooses to cease active membership, contributions already paid cannot be withdrawn as cash and must remain invested until pension access rules permit withdrawal. In these situations, HR should explain clearly that stopping future contributions is different from withdrawing the value already built up and that the latter will remain invested until pension access conditions are met.

Every three years, employers must re-enrol eligible employees, including those who previously ceased membership, and must provide the required statutory communications. Employers must not provide opt-out forms themselves; employees must obtain opt-out notices directly from the scheme or provider, in line with The Pensions Regulator’s guidance. HR must understand these distinctions to remain compliant and avoid inadvertently breaching inducement rules by influencing employees’ decisions about staying in or leaving the scheme.

Section B: Employee Options for Accessing Pension Savings

Employees often approach HR with the belief that withdrawing a workplace pension is a straightforward process. In reality, the options for accessing pension savings are governed by pension tax legislation, scheme rules and the individual’s age or health status. This section outlines the lawful routes available to employees and clarifies where HR involvement begins and ends. Understanding these options helps HR teams respond accurately and support employees without straying into regulated financial advice.

1. Taking pension benefits from age 55+

From the minimum pension age, currently 55 (rising to 57 in 2028), members of defined contribution pension schemes can access their savings in several ways. Access from this age is permitted even if the individual continues working for the same employer.

The primary options include:

• Tax-free lump sum: Up to 25% of the pension pot can usually be taken tax free, subject to the individual’s remaining Lump Sum Allowance (LSA), which replaces the former Lifetime Allowance. The standard LSA is £268,275, unless protected entitlements exist.
• Flexi-access drawdown: Funds are moved into a drawdown account, allowing the member to take income as required. Withdrawals beyond the tax-free amount are taxable. Triggering flexible access may invoke the Money Purchase Annual Allowance (MPAA), reducing the annual allowance for future contributions.
• UFPLS (Uncrystallised Funds Pension Lump Sum): Lump sums taken directly from the pension pot. Each payment is usually 25% tax free and 75% taxable, provided the individual has sufficient remaining LSA. If the LSA is exhausted, the entire UFPLS payment becomes taxable.
• Annuity purchase: The member can buy an annuity providing guaranteed retirement income for life or for a fixed period.

It is important for HR to understand that taking only a Pension Commencement Lump Sum (PCLS) without drawing further taxable income does not trigger the MPAA. However, once flexible access is triggered through taxable drawdown or UFPLS, the MPAA applies and payroll must be updated accordingly once the employee notifies the employer within 91 days.

2. Early access: ill-health rules

Employees who cannot continue working due to illness may qualify for ill-health retirement, depending on the rules of the scheme. Ill-health pension access requires medical evidence and is decided solely by the pension provider or scheme trustees, not the employer. Employers may support the employee in collating evidence but must not express views on eligibility or outcomes.

The two primary categories are:

• Ill-health retirement: Allowed where the employee is permanently incapable of performing their job due to physical or mental impairment, subject to the scheme’s specific ill-health criteria. Benefits may be actuarially reduced depending on the scheme.
• Serious ill-health lump sum: Available when life expectancy is below 12 months and the scheme confirms eligibility. Following the LTA’s abolition, payments are tax free up to the individual’s remaining LSDBA, with any excess taxed at the individual’s marginal rate.

HR’s role is administrative only. HR should support communication with the provider and ensure sensitive handling of the process but must avoid giving views on whether accessing benefits is advisable.

3. Transferring or consolidating pensions

Employees may request information about transferring their workplace pension to another provider, consolidating into a personal pension or combining multiple pots. Transfers are regulated, and schemes must undertake due diligence, particularly to protect against pension scams.

If the workplace pension includes safeguarded benefits, such as a defined benefit guarantee, employees must obtain regulated financial advice before transferring. HR should never recommend whether a transfer is appropriate or beneficial.

HR responsibilities include:

• Confirming employer or payroll details required by the receiving scheme
• Ensuring contributions continue correctly until any transfer takes effect
• Maintaining neutrality and avoiding statements that could be interpreted as financial advice

4. Small pots and trivial commutation

Some pension pots are small enough to be taken as cash under specific rules. These provisions often cause confusion, as employees may believe they allow wider early access when they do not.

Key provisions include:

• Small DC pots: Defined contribution pots below £10,000 can be taken in full. Up to three pots can be taken from personal pension schemes. Occupational scheme small-pot payments may be made without a numeric limit where scheme rules allow.
• Trivial commutation (DB schemes): Defined benefit pots may be taken as cash if the total value of all DB rights across all schemes is below £30,000.
• Tax treatment: Lump sums may include a tax-free portion subject to LSA limits, with the remainder typically taxed as income.

HR should make clear that eligibility for these options depends entirely on scheme rules and provider assessment. HR cannot confirm eligibility or advise an employee on the suitability of withdrawing small pots or commuting DB benefits.

Section Summary: Employees have several lawful ways to access pension savings, primarily after the minimum pension age or under defined ill-health provisions. Options such as drawdown, annuity purchase, small-pot withdrawals and transfers must be processed by the pension provider, not the employer. HR’s role is limited to factual explanation, signposting and ensuring payroll and automatic enrolment compliance without providing regulated advice.

Section C: Tax, Payroll and Compliance Considerations

When employees access pension savings, the consequences extend beyond the pension provider. Withdrawals can trigger tax liabilities, affect ongoing pension contributions and create reporting requirements that HR and payroll teams must handle correctly. This section explains the key tax considerations, employer obligations and compliance risks, giving HR professionals a clear framework for managing pension withdrawal queries while maintaining statutory accuracy and avoiding regulated financial advice.

1. Tax implications of withdrawing pension savings

Most pension withdrawals are taxable, and employees often underestimate the tax consequences. While HR cannot provide personalised tax advice, HR teams must understand the general principles to avoid misinformation and to signpost employees appropriately.

Key tax considerations include:

• Tax-free lump sum entitlement: Typically 25% of the pension pot can be taken tax free, subject to the individual’s remaining Lump Sum Allowance (LSA). The standard LSA is £268,275 unless the member holds valid protections.
• Income tax on withdrawals: Any taxable portion is treated as income and taxed under PAYE. Large withdrawals can push an employee into a higher tax band for that tax year.
• Emergency tax on first withdrawals: Pension providers often apply an emergency tax code until HMRC updates the individual’s record, resulting in possible over-deductions.
• MPAA activation: Once a member flexibly accesses their pension, the Money Purchase Annual Allowance (MPAA) may apply, reducing their annual contribution allowance from £60,000 to £10,000. Simply taking a Pension Commencement Lump Sum (PCLS) does not trigger the MPAA.

HR should signpost employees to HMRC, MoneyHelper or regulated advisers when employees ask about tax outcomes. Employers must not express views about the tax efficiency of particular withdrawal methods, as this may constitute regulated financial advice.

2. Payroll considerations

When pension withdrawals occur, HR and payroll may need to process associated administrative changes, particularly where flexible withdrawals affect contribution levels or require reporting.

Payroll considerations include:

• Interaction with ongoing contributions: If an employee continues to work while taking pension benefits, contributions remain payable unless the employee opts out or ceases active membership.
• Ceasing active membership: If the employee chooses to stop contributing, payroll must amend deductions accordingly without influencing the employee’s choice.
• Notification of flexible access: Employees who flexibly access their pensions must notify the employer within 91 days. Employers must then ensure payroll and pension input records are updated to reflect the reduced MPAA, preventing excess tax relief claims.
• Scheme and provider communication: Payroll may need to liaise with providers to ensure contributions, stop notices and reporting align with scheme requirements.

Payroll accuracy is essential to meet HMRC obligations and to avoid errors that could disadvantage employees or create compliance issues for the employer.

3. Employer risk areas

Responding to pension withdrawal queries carries several compliance and legal risks for employers. HR teams must recognise these risks and structure communications to avoid breach.

Key risks include:

• Giving regulated financial advice: Any suggestion about whether an employee should withdraw their pension, transfer funds or take a lump sum may constitute regulated advice under FCA rules. Comparing options or discussing investment implications also breaches the advice boundary.
• Misrepresenting tax outcomes: Employers must avoid commenting on the tax benefits or disadvantages of specific withdrawal methods.
• Inducement to leave or reduce pension contributions: Automatic enrolment legislation prohibits influencing employees to opt out or cease membership.
• Fraud and scam exposure: Pension scams remain prevalent. HR may provide general warnings but must not advise on specific transfer decisions.

All communications must remain factual, neutral and properly recorded. HR should signpost employees to MoneyHelper, Pension Wise (for those aged 50+) or FCA-regulated advisers.

4. Record-keeping and audit trails

Maintaining accurate records is essential for complying with automatic enrolment duties and demonstrating governance if queried by The Pensions Regulator.

HR teams must ensure:

• Opt-out notices are recorded and retained for at least four years
• Ceasing membership requests are documented accurately
• Pension access and transfer-related communications are documented to demonstrate neutrality and compliance
• Re-enrolment processes occur every three years, with appropriate statutory communications

Strong documentation protects the business in the event of disputes or regulatory audits and supports consistent HR governance.

Section Summary: Pension withdrawals create tax implications, administrative tasks and compliance risks for employers. HR must avoid providing regulated advice while ensuring employees receive accurate, factual information about the tax and payroll consequences of accessing pension savings. Clear record-keeping and understanding employer obligations are central to maintaining compliance.

Section D: HR Best Practice for Managing Pension Withdrawal Queries

Withdrawals from workplace pensions are often prompted by financial stress, uncertainty or misunderstanding. Employees may assume HR can grant permission or expedite access, when in reality employers have no authority to release pension savings and must avoid giving regulated financial advice. This section provides HR professionals and business owners with a structured approach to handling pension withdrawal queries lawfully, consistently and with sensitivity, while maintaining compliance with pension and automatic enrolment legislation.

1. How to handle employee requests appropriately

Employees may request to withdraw their pension for various reasons, including financial difficulty, personal hardship or long-term planning. HR must respond in a way that is factual, legally compliant and supportive without overstepping into prohibited financial advice.

A compliant HR response typically involves:

• Clarifying the employer’s limited role and explaining that only the pension provider can process withdrawals
• Explaining the statutory pension access rules factually, including age thresholds, ill-health conditions and scheme processes
• Signposting employees to their provider, MoneyHelper, Pension Wise (for those aged 50+) or regulated financial advisers
• Avoiding prescriptive advice or opinions on whether accessing pension savings is beneficial or harmful
• Encouraging written communication where appropriate to ensure clarity and an auditable record

HR should ensure all communications remain neutral and consistent to reduce the risk of misunderstandings or inadvertent inducement.

2. Managing opt-outs and ceasing membership

Many employees requesting to “withdraw” their pension are in fact seeking to stop future contributions. HR must manage these requests in line with statutory automatic enrolment obligations.

Key points include:

• Opt-out period limitations: Employees may only receive a refund of contributions if they opt out within one month of automatic enrolment. Refunds of both employer and employee contributions are processed by the pension scheme, not the employer.
• Ceasing active membership: Employees may stop contributing at any time after the opt-out window, but contributions already paid remain invested until pension access age or other lawful conditions are met.
• No employer inducement: Employers must avoid encouraging employees to leave or reduce pension contributions, whether explicitly or indirectly. Any such conduct may breach the Pensions Act 2008.
• Re-enrolment duties: Every three years, employers must re-enrol eligible employees, including those who ceased membership. Employers must not provide opt-out forms; these must be obtained directly from the scheme.

HR’s role is to ensure these processes are administered correctly, communicated clearly and handled in a way that avoids influencing employee decisions.

3. Addressing financial vulnerability and safeguarding concerns

Increasing numbers of employees seek pension access due to financial pressure. HR professionals may be the first to detect vulnerability or signs of financial distress, and must handle such situations sensitively while remaining within legal boundaries.

HR should:

• Remain alert to pension scams and provide general warnings without advising for or against specific transfers
• Encourage employees experiencing financial difficulty to seek impartial guidance from MoneyHelper, Citizens Advice or internal support systems such as an Employee Assistance Programme
• Ensure employees aged 50 or over are aware of Pension Wise guidance
• Maintain confidentiality and treat disclosures sensitively

HR must not recommend withdrawing pension funds or transferring pensions in response to financial pressure. Such advice would be regulated and may expose the employer to legal liability.

4. Internal policy considerations

HR teams benefit from having clear internal processes for managing pension withdrawal queries to ensure consistency, legal compliance and reduced organisational risk.

Policies should cover:

• Standardised communication scripts or templates ensuring HR responses remain factual and non-advisory
• Record-keeping requirements for opt-outs, membership cessation and pension-related communications
• Staff training so HR generalists and payroll teams understand statutory access rules, advice boundaries and automatic enrolment duties
• Escalation pathways for complex queries, including when to refer employees to the provider or external advisers

A well-structured internal approach ensures regulatory compliance, reduces employer risk and supports employees with accurate and consistent information.

Section Summary: HR’s best practice approach to pension withdrawal queries involves clear communication, adherence to statutory access rules, and strict avoidance of regulated financial advice. Managing opt-outs, supporting vulnerable employees, maintaining strong record-keeping and implementing robust internal policies all help employers meet their pension duties and regulatory obligations.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can an employee withdraw their workplace pension before age 55?

Generally no. Pension savings cannot be accessed before the minimum pension age (currently 55, rising to 57 in 2028) unless the employee qualifies for ill-health or serious ill-health retirement under scheme rules. Financial hardship alone is not a lawful ground for early access. Eligibility decisions rest with the pension provider or trustees, not the employer.

What should HR do if an employee insists they need their pension early?

HR should explain the statutory restrictions on early access and the limited circumstances in which early withdrawal may be possible. HR should signpost the employee to their pension provider for full details, and to MoneyHelper, Pension Wise (for those aged 50+), or regulated financial advisers for guidance. If the employee expresses financial distress, HR should direct them to internal support routes where available. HR must not provide regulated advice or influence an employee’s decision.

Can an employer stop an employee from opting out of the workplace pension?

No. Employees may opt out during the statutory opt-out window, and employers must process valid opt-out notices correctly. Employers must not influence or encourage employees to opt out or cease membership, since this is treated as an inducement under the Pensions Act 2008. Employers must also re-enrol eligible employees every three years.

Are employers allowed to advise on pension withdrawals?

No. Employers cannot provide regulated financial advice unless FCA-authorised. This includes offering opinions on whether withdrawing pension savings is beneficial, whether funds should be transferred, or comparing withdrawal options. HR may give factual information only and must signpost to regulated advice where needed.

What happens if an employee withdraws pension savings while still employed?

Employees who meet the pension access criteria may take benefits while remaining in employment. Payroll may need to adjust pension input reporting if the employee has flexibly accessed their pension, as this can trigger the Money Purchase Annual Allowance (MPAA). Pension withdrawals do not remove the employer’s duty to continue automatic enrolment contributions unless the employee opts out or ceases active membership.

Conclusion

Workplace pension withdrawals are often misunderstood by employees, but for HR professionals and business owners the rules are clear: pension access is controlled by statutory pension and tax legislation, not by the employer. Employees cannot withdraw pension savings on demand, and contributions already paid generally remain invested until the minimum pension access age or specific early-access criteria are met.

The employer’s responsibilities sit within automatic enrolment compliance, accurate payroll administration and clear, consistent communication. HR must avoid giving regulated financial advice while still providing factual explanations about scheme rules, tax implications and the employee’s available options. Understanding the difference between withdrawing pension savings, opting out of automatic enrolment and ceasing active membership is critical for managing employee expectations and meeting legal obligations.

HR professionals should also remain alert to issues of vulnerability, pension scams and financial distress, ensuring employees receive appropriate signposting to MoneyHelper, Pension Wise (for those aged 50+) or regulated advisers. Strong internal processes, careful record-keeping and staff training support consistent governance and reduce legal risk.

By approaching pension withdrawal queries systematically and lawfully, HR teams can protect the business, support employees appropriately and uphold the employer’s statutory duties across payroll, pensions and automatic enrolment.

Glossary

Useful Links