Can You Be Forced to Work Overtime UK?

Overtime can be a significant operational tool for UK employers, particularly during periods of high demand, staffing shortages or time-critical projects. Yet whether an employer can require an employee to work additional hours is governed by a combination of contractual obligations, statutory protections and limits under the Working Time Regulations 1998 (WTR). HR teams must be clear on these rules to avoid disputes, unlawful instructions or health and safety breaches.

What this article is about: This guide explains when overtime can legally be required, how contractual terms shape an employee’s obligation to work additional hours and where the Working Time Regulations restrict an employer’s discretion. It also incorporates considerations arising from custom and practice (in rare cases), the implied duty of mutual trust and confidence, and the need for employers to follow the ACAS Code of Practice when responding to refusals. The article provides a detailed examination of employee rights, statutory limits, rest protections, zero-hours worker restrictions, health and safety duties under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 and equality considerations under the Equality Act 2010.

The content is designed for HR professionals and business owners responsible for managing workforce deployment and compliance. It provides detailed legal analysis, practical risk points and structured guidance on how to implement and manage overtime arrangements lawfully in the UK.

Section A: Legal Basis of Overtime in UK Employment Law

Overtime sits at the intersection of contract law and statutory working time protections. For HR professionals, the starting point is always the employment contract, which determines whether overtime can be required and in what circumstances. Statutory rules then operate as safeguards to ensure employees are not compelled to work excessive hours or placed at risk through extended working patterns.

1. What overtime means in UK employment law

Overtime refers to hours worked beyond an employee’s normal contractual hours. UK law does not create a standalone statutory definition of overtime. Instead, overtime is a contractual construct shaped by the terms agreed between employer and employee. Where contractual hours are fixed, any additional time beyond those hours is treated as overtime. Where contractual hours are variable, overtime may arise only when work exceeds a particular threshold defined in the contract or policy.

For HR teams, clarity is essential. The contract should specify normal working hours, how additional hours will be handled and whether the organisation reserves the right to require overtime. In most cases, this clarity will be achieved through express terms, though in rare situations a consistent and well-understood custom and practice may contribute to how overtime is treated in the workplace.

2. Types of overtime clauses

Employers may rely on several different types of overtime provisions, each carrying distinct legal implications:

• Voluntary overtime: Employees can choose whether to work extra hours. There is no obligation to accept.
• Compulsory overtime: Employees must work additional hours when instructed, provided the contract expressly permits this.
• Guaranteed overtime: The employer is contractually required to offer specified overtime, and the employee is obliged to work it.
• Non-guaranteed overtime: The employer is not obliged to offer overtime, but when it is offered the employee must work it.

Understanding the type of clause in place is key to determining whether overtime can be enforced and how far an employer can rely on instructions to work additional hours.

3. When overtime can legally be required

An employee can only be forced to work overtime where the employment contract contains a clear and enforceable compulsory overtime clause. Without such a clause, the instruction will generally be voluntary and the employee may refuse. Even where a compulsory overtime clause exists, the employer’s right is constrained by statutory rules on maximum working hours, rest breaks, equality law and overall health and safety obligations.

Contracts should avoid vague or ambiguous wording. Courts and tribunals generally interpret unclear clauses in favour of the employee, reducing the employer’s ability to enforce overtime. While, in limited circumstances, a long-standing, certain and well-understood custom and practice might help to imply obligations around additional hours, employers should not rely on this. From a risk management perspective, express and well-drafted overtime terms are strongly preferable.

4. Interaction with the Working Time Regulations

The Working Time Regulations 1998 (WTR) impose limits on weekly working hours and minimum rest periods. These rules apply regardless of contractual terms. In practice, this means compulsory overtime cannot push an employee beyond the statutory limits unless the employee has voluntarily signed a valid opt-out from the 48-hour average working week. The 48-hour limit is generally calculated as an average over a 17-week reference period, subject to any sector-specific or collectively agreed alternative reference periods.

The WTR also require that, subject to limited derogations:

• daily rest of at least 11 consecutive hours between shifts
• weekly rest of at least 24 hours (or 48 hours every 14 days)
• rest breaks during the working day where applicable.

HR teams must review overtime instructions in the context of these limits before requiring additional hours, ensuring that both individual and collective working patterns remain compliant.

5. Section summary

Overtime in the UK is primarily governed by contractual terms, supported by statutory protections in the Working Time Regulations 1998. Employers can only compel overtime where a clear clause exists and where statutory time and rest limits are respected, including the 48-hour average weekly limit calculated over the relevant reference period. A well-drafted contract and policy framework, underpinned by accurate working time records and awareness of custom and practice risks, is the foundation for lawful and effective overtime management.

Section B: Can an Employee Be Forced to Work Overtime?

Whether overtime can be enforced depends on the contractual relationship and the statutory limits governing working time. HR professionals must distinguish between a lawful compulsory instruction and an unenforceable request, as the consequences for employee relations, health and safety and legal compliance can be significant.

1. When compulsory overtime is enforceable

Compulsory overtime is only enforceable when the employment contract expressly provides for it. The clause must be clear, unambiguous and communicated to the employee at the point of engagement. For example, a contract may state that the employee is required to work “additional hours as reasonably necessary to meet business needs”. In such cases, the employer may instruct overtime, provided the requirement is genuinely reasonable, complies with the Working Time Regulations and respects wider employment protections, including the implied term of mutual trust and confidence.

Policies alone cannot impose mandatory overtime unless they are expressly incorporated into the contract. If the provision sits only in a handbook and is not referenced contractually as a binding term, the overtime requirement will not be enforceable.

2. Validity and enforceability of overtime clauses

Overtime clauses must comply with general principles of contract law. An instruction to work overtime must fall within the scope of the clause, and the clause must not be drafted so widely that it undermines statutory protections or risks being deemed unreasonable. Employers must ensure that instructions remain proportionate and consistent with their duty of mutual trust and confidence.

Where a clause requires employees to work “any additional hours required”, employers should apply the provision proportionately. If the instruction goes beyond what is reasonably necessary, the employee may challenge its enforceability. Similarly, if the clause has not been clearly explained or brought to the employee’s attention, its enforceability may be weakened.

3. When an employee can lawfully refuse overtime

Employees may lawfully refuse to work overtime in several situations:

• No contractual obligation: If overtime is voluntary, the employee cannot be forced to work additional hours.
• Statutory limits: Employees who have not opted out of the 48-hour average weekly limit cannot be required to exceed it.
• Health and safety risks: Employees may refuse overtime where the instruction would create an unsafe working pattern.
• Discrimination or unfair allocation: If overtime is allocated in a discriminatory or retaliatory manner, employees may raise grievances or refuse on reasonable grounds. This includes risks of indirect discrimination under the Equality Act 2010, for example where childcare needs disproportionately affect women.

Refusal may also be justified where the employer has not given reasonable notice, where statutory rest periods would be breached or where the instruction conflicts with the employer’s duty of mutual trust and confidence.

4. The impact of the 48-hour weekly limit and opt-out rules

The Working Time Regulations cap the average working week at 48 hours unless the employee signs a voluntary opt-out. Without a signed opt-out, any instruction requiring overtime that would push the employee beyond this average limit is unenforceable, even with a compulsory overtime clause in place. The default reference period for calculating average hours is 17 weeks, though some sectors and collective agreements may adopt alternative periods.

The opt-out must be voluntary and in writing. Employees cannot be subjected to detriment for refusing to sign it. Employers should track working hours to ensure that compulsory overtime does not inadvertently breach the Regulations and that instructions remain compatible with health and safety obligations.

5. Section summary

An employee can only be required to work overtime if a clear contractual obligation exists and the instruction complies with statutory working time limits, equality law and the employer’s wider duty of trust and confidence. Employees retain the right to refuse overtime where the contract does not mandate it, where the instruction is unreasonable or where statutory protections would be breached. HR teams should ensure that overtime practices are clearly documented, proportionate and non-discriminatory, and that any disciplinary responses align with contractual rights and the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures.

Section C: Pay, Hours and Rest Requirements

Overtime arrangements must account not only for contractual obligations but also for statutory rules on pay, minimum wage compliance and mandatory rest breaks. Employers may require additional hours where contracts allow, but HR teams must ensure that these instructions do not inadvertently breach pay regulations or working time protections.

1. Overtime pay requirements: contract vs statutory rights

There is no statutory right in the UK to enhanced overtime pay. Whether overtime attracts a premium rate is determined by the employment contract or an incorporated policy. If the contract states that overtime will be paid, the employer must honour the specified rate.

Where no enhanced rate applies, employers must still ensure that overtime does not cause average pay to fall below the National Minimum Wage (NMW) or National Living Wage (NLW). Compliance is assessed over the relevant pay reference period rather than on a shift-by-shift basis. Employers therefore need to monitor total hours worked and total pay received during each pay reference period to ensure statutory thresholds are met.

2. National Minimum Wage compliance

For hourly paid workers, NMW calculations are relatively straightforward, but salaried or output-based workers may require more detailed assessment. HR teams must track total hours worked—including overtime—and ensure that average hourly pay for each pay reference period meets or exceeds the statutory minimum.

Problems may arise where overtime is required but the contract does not specify an enhanced rate, or where salaried workers perform significant additional hours. Any failure to comply with minimum wage obligations exposes the employer to arrears, penalties and public naming.

3. Rest breaks, daily rest and weekly rest requirements

Overtime must not compromise statutory rest entitlements under the Working Time Regulations. Employers must ensure compliance with the following minimum standards, subject to limited derogations:

• Rest breaks: 20 minutes when working more than six hours
• Daily rest: 11 consecutive hours between shifts
• Weekly rest: 24 hours per week or 48 hours per fortnight

Scheduling overtime that infringes these minimums exposes the organisation to legal risk and potential enforcement action. Young workers benefit from more stringent protections under the Working Time Regulations (Young Workers), meaning they cannot ordinarily be required to work overtime unless specific conditions are satisfied and adult workers are unavailable. Where an exception is applied, employers must document why it was necessary and how compensatory rest will be provided.

4. Night workers and special protections

Night workers are entitled to additional statutory protections, including limits on average night work and mandatory health assessments. Overtime instructions for night workers must respect:

• an average limit of 8 hours night work in each 24-hour period (subject to sectoral derogations such as emergency services, security and seasonal work)
• requirements for regular health assessments
• the obligation to prevent work patterns that could endanger health or safety.

Where derogations apply, employers must still ensure compensatory rest is provided. Overtime for night workers therefore requires heightened monitoring and risk assessment.

5. Section summary

While overtime pay is largely determined by contract, employers must ensure compliance with statutory minimum wage rules and working time protections. Rest requirements, young worker safeguards, night work obligations and pay reference period calculations must all be factored into overtime planning. Rigorous monitoring helps employers avoid breaches and maintain a safe working environment.

Section D: Managing Overtime in the Workplace

Effective overtime management requires a structured approach that balances business needs with legal compliance and employee wellbeing. HR teams play a central role in designing clear contractual provisions, monitoring hours, allocating work fairly and handling refusal or grievances.

1. Drafting overtime terms in contracts and policies

A clear contractual framework is essential for enforceable overtime. Contracts should specify:

• normal working hours
• whether overtime may be required
• the circumstances in which additional hours may be instructed
• any enhanced rates or compensatory time-off arrangements
• how overtime is approved or recorded.

Where a handbook or policy sets out more detailed rules, it must be incorporated into the contract if the employer intends the overtime provisions to be binding. HR should ensure wording avoids ambiguity, as unclear clauses reduce enforceability and increase the risk of disputes.

2. Considering health, safety and wellbeing risks

Overtime can strain workforce capacity and create risks associated with fatigue. Employers have a statutory duty under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 to ensure, so far as reasonably practicable, the health, safety and welfare of their employees. This duty requires employers to evaluate whether proposed overtime creates risks that cannot be managed safely.

Before requiring overtime, HR should assess:

• whether the employee is already working near the 48-hour average weekly limit
• any risks arising from consecutive or extended shifts
• the impact of overtime on mental and physical wellbeing
• whether adjustments or compensatory rest are required.

Where a pattern of excessive overtime emerges, HR should review staffing levels and explore structural solutions rather than relying on ongoing additional hours.

3. Avoiding discriminatory allocation of overtime

Overtime must be allocated fairly and without discrimination. Employers should avoid patterns that disadvantage particular protected groups under the Equality Act 2010. For example, consistently offering overtime only to certain demographic groups or penalising those with childcare or disability-related constraints can lead to claims of indirect discrimination.

Transparent criteria for offering or assigning overtime help reduce risk. HR should maintain records demonstrating that decisions are based on operational need rather than personal characteristics or assumptions.

4. Managing refusals, grievances and reasonable instructions

Where compulsory overtime exists, refusals must be managed consistently and proportionately. HR should consider whether:

• the instruction was reasonable and fell within the scope of the contractual clause
• statutory limits and rest requirements were respected
• adequate notice was provided
• any health, safety or personal circumstances justify refusal.

Disciplinary action should only be taken where the refusal breaches a clear contractual obligation and the employer’s instruction was lawful, proportionate and compliant with the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures. If an employee raises a grievance alleging unfair treatment or discrimination, HR must investigate promptly and objectively.

5. Section summary

Overtime management requires contractual clarity, careful allocation and proactive health and safety oversight. HR teams should ensure overtime clauses are unambiguous, monitor compliance with statutory working time rules and handle refusals or grievances with consistency and fairness. Attention to equality obligations, wellbeing considerations and the ACAS Code helps employers balance operational demands with legal compliance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an employer discipline someone for refusing overtime?
Yes, but only where a valid compulsory overtime clause exists and the instruction was lawful, reasonable and compliant with statutory limits, equality considerations and the employer’s duty of mutual trust and confidence. Any disciplinary response must also align with the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures.

Can overtime be mandatory without a written contract?
Mandatory overtime cannot be enforced without a contractual basis. If the contract does not expressly permit compulsory overtime, the employee cannot be required to work additional hours. Implied terms alone are rarely sufficient, although in limited circumstances a clear and established custom and practice may inform how overtime is treated. Employers should not rely on this when seeking to enforce mandatory overtime.

Can zero-hours workers be forced to work overtime?
Zero-hours workers cannot be required to accept overtime or additional shifts. Any clause attempting to require acceptance of further hours may amount to an unlawful exclusivity term under the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015. However, employers may offer additional hours, which the worker is free to accept or decline.

Do salaried employees have to work overtime for no extra pay?
A salaried worker may be contractually obliged to work additional hours without extra pay if the contract states that salary covers all required hours. However, the employer must still ensure that average pay does not fall below the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage for the relevant pay reference period once all hours worked are included.

Does overtime count towards the 48-hour weekly limit?
Yes. All working time, including overtime, counts towards the 48-hour average weekly limit under the Working Time Regulations unless the employee has voluntarily signed a written opt-out. The average is typically calculated over a 17-week reference period unless an alternative applies.

Conclusion

Overtime can support business continuity and operational resilience, but employers cannot compel additional hours unless a clear contractual right exists and statutory working time protections are satisfied. HR teams must review contracts, track working hours and ensure employees are not placed under unreasonable pressure to exceed safe limits. The Working Time Regulations underpin all overtime decisions, while fairness, transparency and proportionality help maintain trust and reduce dispute risk.

A structured approach to drafting overtime clauses, allocating work and managing refusals enables employers to meet operational needs while staying compliant with UK employment law. Attention to equality duties, wellbeing considerations and the employer’s wider obligations under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 and the ACAS Code of Practice ensures that overtime practices remain both lawful and sustainable.

Glossary

Useful Links