Right to Work Law & Employer Obligations
Your complete guide to the law behind UK Right to Work checks.
Confidence in compliance
starts with clarity
of the rules.
Right to Work employer obligations are the legal duties every UK organisation has to prevent illegal working.
In practice, that means checking each person before they start, rechecking anyone whose permission runs out and keeping the evidence.
What meeting your Right to Work obligations involves
The risk is in the everday detail. A check made a day late, a missed follow-up or a lost copy can leave you without a defence to a civil penalty of up to £60,000 per worker.
Employing someone you know, or have reasonable cause to believe, is working illegally is a criminal offence, and a breach can put a sponsor licence at risk. Checking some people more closely than others brings its own risk of discrimination claims.
Our Right to Work Law and Employer Obligations resources explain who you have to check, what the law requires and how to protect your business if something goes wrong.
RESOURCES
Right to Work Law
Everything UK employers need to know about their obligations under the Right to Work regime.
RIGHT TO WORK CHECK REQUIREMENTS
- What does the law require employers to do to prevent illegal working?
- Which legislation and codes of practice govern Right to Work checks?
- When must a check be completed and what records must be kept?
- What changed in the legal requirements on 1 October 2026?
WHO NEEDS A RIGHT TO WORK CHECK?
- Which workers and working arrangements fall within the Right to Work Scheme?
- Do British and Irish citizens need a Right to Work check?
- Are contractors, agency workers and platform workers covered?
- When does a business-to-business contract fall outside the scheme?
RIGHT TO WORK STATUTORY EXCUSE
- What is a statutory excuse and how does an employer establish one?
- What is the difference between a continuous and a time-limited excuse?
- When can an employer lose the statutory excuse?
- How can a business protect itself against extended liability in its supply chain?
RIGHT TO WORK CHECKS & DISCRIMINATION
- How can Right to Work checks give rise to unlawful discrimination?
- What does the Home Office code on avoiding discrimination expect of employers?
- Can an employer insist on a particular checking method?
- How should employers treat applicants with eVisas or pending applications?
LEGAL ADVICE
Fixed-fee,
no-obligation
Speak to one of our experienced experts for legal advice specific to your organisation.
BOOK A CONSULTATIONBusiness Immigration & Workforce Compliance Solicitors
We help employers improve workforce compliance, reduce immigration risk and respond effectively when problems arise.
Right to Work Audits
Gaps in right to work records or checking procedures can leave employers exposed to civil penalties, enforcement action and wider reputational risk.
We review your existing records, processes and documentation, identify areas of concern and recommend practical steps to strengthen compliance.
Learn more about Right to Work audits →
Right to Work Training
Managers and HR teams can expose the business to compliance risk if right to work checks are carried out incorrectly or inconsistently.
We provide practical training, including e-learning options, tailored to your organisation, helping relevant staff understand how to conduct compliant checks, identify issues and know when to escalate them.
Learn more about Right to Work training →
Right to Work Investigations & Enforcement Support
If the Home Office is investigating your organisation for immigration compliance, we can help.
We advise employers facing suspected illegal working, Home Office investigations, civil penalty notices and related sponsor licence risks, helping businesses assess their position, respond to enforcement action and protect their operations.
SECTION GUIDE
Right to Work Law & Employer Obligations
Section A: What This Guide Covers
Right to Work employer obligations form the legal foundation of the UK's illegal working regime. Every organisation that engages people to do work or provide services in the UK needs to know whether the Right to Work Scheme applies to each engagement, what a compliant check involves and what follows if an illegal worker is found. The same statutory framework applies in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.
The guide is for employers, HR and recruitment teams, procurement and compliance functions and businesses that use contractors, agency staff, labour providers or online platforms. It reflects the law in force at 18 November 2026, including the extension of the scheme that took effect on 1 October 2026.
Our Right to Work Checks: Complete UK Employer Guide shows how these obligations play out in practice, and our guide to UK Right to Work Changes 2026 explains the October 2026 reforms.
Section B: The Right to Work Legal Framework
The Right to Work legal framework operates on three levels. Primary legislation creates civil penalty liability for illegal working, the statutory excuse and the criminal offence. Statutory instruments prescribe the checks an organisation must carry out to rely on the excuse and set the maximum penalty. Statutory codes of practice and Home Office guidance then explain how the Home Office applies the scheme and calculates penalties.
Each level answers a different question for an employer. The legislation decides whether liability arises, the prescribed requirements decide whether the employer is protected and the codes decide how much a penalty is likely to be. Compliance procedures need to reflect all three.
1. The Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006
The Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 is the principal statute governing illegal working in the UK. Its employment provisions, in sections 14A to 25, contain the civil penalty scheme, the objection and appeal process, enforcement, the power to issue codes of practice, the criminal offence and the duty to issue a code on avoiding discrimination.
Section 15 makes it contrary to the Act to employ an adult subject to immigration control in three situations: where the person has not been granted leave to enter or remain in the UK; where their leave is invalid or has ceased to have effect, whether through curtailment, revocation, cancellation, passage of time or otherwise; and where their leave is subject to a condition preventing them from accepting the employment. An employer that acts contrary to section 15 may be given a notice requiring it to pay a civil penalty of a specified amount, up to the prescribed maximum.
Section 15(3) excuses an employer from paying the penalty if it has complied with requirements prescribed by order. Section 15(4) removes that excuse where the employer knew, at any time during the employment, that the employment was contrary to section 15. The Home Office may issue a penalty notice without first establishing whether the excuse applies, and the notice must state why the employer is thought to be liable and the amount of the penalty.1
The remaining sections build out the scheme. Section 16 allows an employer to object to a penalty notice and section 17 provides for an appeal to the court. Section 18 allows the Home Office to recover an unpaid penalty as a debt, and in enforcement proceedings no question may be raised about liability, the application of the excuse or the amount. Section 19 requires the Secretary of State to issue a code of practice on the factors used to determine the amount of a penalty and section 20 governs the orders made under the scheme. Section 21 creates the criminal offence of employing an illegal worker, section 22 applies it to bodies corporate, partnerships and their officers and section 23 requires a code of practice on avoiding unlawful discrimination.
2. The October 2026 Extension of the Right to Work Scheme
Section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 amended the 2006 Act by inserting new sections 14A and 15A and making consequential changes to the interpretation provisions in section 25.2 The Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 (Commencement No. 4) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/683) brought section 48 into force on 1 October 2026.3
Section 14A applies sections 15 to 24 to three working arrangements in addition to employment under a contract of service or apprenticeship. The first is engaging an individual under a worker's contract. The second is engaging an individual subcontractor. The third is operating an online matching service that provides a service provider's details to potential clients or customers. References to employment, employers and employees in those sections are read to include the parties to each arrangement, and a contract may be express or implied and, if express, oral or written.
Section 15A extends liability under section 15 beyond the party in a direct contractual relationship with the worker. A business that has contracted to provide, or arrange the provision of, work or services and then passes all or part of that work to another person under a contract can be treated as employing any individual who personally does the work. An online matching service can be treated in the same way where a client contracts with a service provider as a result of the match. The deemed employment applies even where the business has no contract with the individual and does not know that the individual is doing the work, and it applies whether the contract is the first in a chain or a later one. Section 15A leaves the liability of any other employer under section 15 intact.2
The Home Office code of practice identifies three settings in which extended liability operates: contractual chains, online matching services and employment contracts that allow the worker to send a substitute. The code also confirms that the extended definition of employer applies in relation to the Right to Work Scheme only.4 Employment status for the purposes of employment rights, tax and other areas of law continues to be decided under those separate regimes, so an organisation can owe Right to Work obligations to an individual who remains self-employed for every other purpose.
3. Secondary Legislation and the Prescribed Requirements
The checks that give an employer a statutory excuse are prescribed in the Immigration (Restrictions on Employment) Order 2007 (SI 2007/3290).5 The Order specifies the documents and online processes an employer may rely on, what the employer must do with them and whether the resulting excuse is continuous or time-limited. A check that departs from the prescribed steps does not give the employer the protection of section 15(3), even if the individual in fact has permission to work.
The Immigration (Restrictions on Employment and Residential Accommodation) (Prescribed Requirements and Codes of Practice) (Amendment) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/700) amended the 2007 Order from 1 October 2026. Among other changes, the Regulations insert a new article 5B setting out the prescribed requirements for engagements outside a traditional contract of employment, including the contractual requirements that protect a business against extended liability.6
The maximum amount of a civil penalty is set by a separate order made under section 15(2) of the 2006 Act. Section F explains the current maximum and how the Home Office arrives at the amount in an individual case.
4. Codes of Practice and Home Office Guidance
The Code of practice on preventing illegal working: Right to Work Scheme for employers is issued under section 19 of the 2006 Act and sets out the factors the Home Office considers when determining the amount of a civil penalty. The current version is the seventh, in force from 1 October 2026, and replaces the version issued in January 2024. It applies when calculating a penalty for a breach of section 15 on or after 1 October 2026 and when determining liability where a required initial check, repeat check or extended liability requirement fell on or after that date. Checks carried out earlier are judged against the code in force at the time.4
The Employer's guide to Right to Work checks explains how to carry out each type of check and how the Home Office interprets the prescribed requirements. The current version was published on 1 October 2026, updating the version of 16 July 2026, and came into force on the same day.7 The Code of practice for employers: avoiding unlawful discrimination while preventing illegal working, issued under section 23, was revised at the same time and has been in force since 1 October 2026.8
The codes and the guide carry different legal weight. The penalty code is a statutory code, and a court hearing an appeal against a civil penalty must have regard to it when considering the amount.4 The Employer's guide is Home Office guidance: it sets out the Home Office's interpretation of the prescribed requirements but does not itself have the force of law. Where guidance appears to go further than, or differ from, the 2006 Act or the 2007 Order, the legislation governs and the point should be checked before an organisation relies on it.
Detailed checking requirements now appear in both the Employer's guide and the penalty code. Organisations should read the two documents together and review their procedures whenever either is updated.
Section C: Right to Work Checks: Employer Legal Requirements
Right to Work checks are the means by which an organisation meets its legal requirements under the illegal working scheme. The 2006 Act imposes civil penalty liability for employing an illegal worker and gives the employer a statutory excuse if it has completed the prescribed checks. The Home Office describes the result as a legal duty on all employers in the UK to prevent illegal working.7
A compliant check uses a prescribed method and is completed before the work starts. It confirms that the individual may do the particular work offered and it is properly recorded. Where permission is time-limited, the check must also be repeated at the right time. Each element is covered below, and our Right to Work Checks: Employer Legal Requirements guide examines them in more detail.
1. Completing a Prescribed Check Before Work Starts
A Right to Work check must be completed before the individual starts work. The Employer's guide recognises three prescribed methods: a manual document-based check, a Home Office online check and a check carried out through a Right to Work digital verification service provider (RtW DVSP). An employer cannot dictate which of the prescribed methods available in the individual's circumstances is used and must give them a reasonable opportunity to prove their Right to Work.7
Each method has its own prescribed steps, covering how the evidence is obtained, how the employer satisfies itself that the evidence relates to the person in front of it and what record must be kept. Using the wrong method for a particular individual, or missing one of its steps, leaves the employer without a statutory excuse. Our Right to Work Checks: Complete UK Employer Guide sets out each process step by step.
Some individuals cannot prove their Right to Work through any of the three methods, for example because they cannot provide a share code while they have an outstanding immigration application, administrative review or appeal. In those cases the employer may be able to request confirmation from the Home Office Employer Checking Service. A Positive Verification Notice gives the employer a time-limited statutory excuse, and our Employer Checking Service guide explains when a request can be made.
The timing requirement is strict. A check completed after the individual has started work does not give the employer an excuse for the period before the check, and any illegal working in that period exposes the employer to a penalty.
2. Confirming That the Individual May Do the Work Offered
A Right to Work check establishes the individual's entitlement to do the specific work offered as well as their identity and status. Section 15 treats a person whose leave is subject to a condition preventing them from accepting the employment in the same way as a person with no leave at all, so an employer that engages someone in breach of their visa conditions can face a penalty even though the individual is lawfully in the UK.
Immigration conditions commonly restrict the employer, the occupation, the number of hours or the type of activity. A Skilled Worker is generally permitted to work only in their sponsored role and in limited supplementary employment. A Student with permission to work is subject to limits on term-time hours and cannot be self-employed unless they have made an in-time application for the Innovator Founder route, supported by an endorsement from an endorsing body, and that application remains outstanding. Where a student's permission restricts term-time working, the employer must obtain and keep evidence of the student's academic term and vacation dates for the period of the employment.7
The employer's check therefore needs to compare the role on offer, including its hours, duties and contractual basis, with the conditions shown in the evidence. Our guides to Skilled Worker visa work restrictions and Student visa working hours explain the conditions employers are most likely to encounter.
3. Follow-Up Checks Where Permission Is Time-Limited
A follow-up check is required where an individual's permission to work is time-limited. The statutory excuse in those cases lasts only as long as the permission shown in the evidence, and the employer keeps it by carrying out a further prescribed check on or before the date it expires.4
Holders of pre-settled status under the EU Settlement Scheme are an exception. After a compliant initial check, no repeat check is required for them.7
Expiry of the excuse does not always mean that the individual's Right to Work has ended. A person who made a valid application to extend their permission before it expired may have continuing leave under section 3C of the Immigration Act 1971, on the same conditions as before, while the application and any administrative review or appeal are pending. Where the individual holds an eVisa, the employer should use the Home Office online service, which can confirm the pending application and gives a statutory excuse for six months. The Employer Checking Service is used where the individual cannot provide a share code. For an existing worker with an outstanding application, administrative review or appeal, or a long-term resident who arrived before 1988, the employer's statutory excuse continues for up to 28 calendar days from the expiry of the worker's permission while it carries out the online check or obtains a Positive Verification Notice. That period does not apply to checks carried out before employment starts.7
Ending an engagement automatically when a recorded visa date passes can expose an employer to unfair dismissal and discrimination claims where the individual still has permission to work. Our guides to follow-up Right to Work checks and section 3C leave explain how to manage these situations.
4. Retaining Records of the Check
Evidence of each Right to Work check must be kept securely for the duration of the employment and for two years after it ends and then securely destroyed. The retention period applies to manual checks, online checks and checks through an RtW DVSP.7 The record should also show when the check was carried out, since the statutory excuse depends on the check having been completed before the work started.
Licensed sponsors carry a further duty. Appendix D to the sponsor guidance requires a sponsor to keep evidence of Right to Work checks on any worker it employs, or is treated as employing for the purposes of the Right to Work Scheme, even if it does not sponsor them, and on every worker it sponsors, whatever the working arrangement.9 Missing Right to Work records can therefore lead to action against a sponsor licence as well as a civil penalty.
Right to Work records contain personal data and must be held and destroyed in line with data protection law. Our Right to Work Record Keeping and Expiry Monitoring guide covers retention, storage and expiry monitoring in detail.
5. What Changed in the Legal Requirements on 1 October 2026
Several changes to the checking requirements took effect on 1 October 2026 alongside the extension of the scheme. Where an organisation relies on digital identity verification, the check must now be carried out through a registered RtW DVSP.4 Organisations engaging workers, individual subcontractors and service providers through online platforms now need checking procedures for those arrangements as well as for employees.
The changes do not operate retrospectively. For worker's contracts, individual subcontractors and online matching services, a civil penalty may be imposed only where the employment or engagement began on or after 1 October 2026.7 An arrangement that began before that date does not come within scope solely because the work continues. Follow-up checks carried out after 1 October 2026 must meet the legislation and guidance in force when each check is made.
For employees, a contract of employment falls within the civil penalty scheme where the employment began on or after 29 February 2008, and checks completed correctly under earlier versions of the requirements remain valid.4 Our UK Right to Work Changes 2026 guide sets out the full list of changes.
Section D: Who Needs a Right to Work Check?
A Right to Work check is needed for every individual an organisation employs, or is treated as employing, under the Right to Work Scheme. Since 1 October 2026 that group extends well beyond employees on the payroll. The scope of the scheme now depends on the nature of each working arrangement, and organisations need to classify their engagements accurately before they can allocate checking responsibility.
Scope operates at two levels. Section 14A decides who is a direct employer for the purposes of the scheme and therefore needs to carry out a prescribed check. Section 15A decides when a business that does not engage the individual directly can still be liable for a penalty. Both are covered in this section, and our Who Needs a Right to Work Check? guide works through further examples.
1. The Four Categories Within the Right to Work Scheme
The Right to Work Scheme now covers four categories of engagement, each defined in the 2006 Act and summarised in the Home Office code:4
- Employees and apprentices: Individuals employed under a contract of employment, meaning a contract of service or apprenticeship.
- Worker's contracts: Contracts, other than contracts of employment or apprenticeship, under which an individual personally does work or services for another person, where that person is not a client or customer of the individual's own profession or business.
- Individual subcontractors: Individuals who contract with a person to provide work or services that the person has itself contracted with a third party to provide or arrange, where the individual has not made a contract with that third party.
- Online matching services: Businesses that keep a register of service providers, run an online service through which potential clients or customers can submit enquiries to be matched with them and charge a fee or commission for making matches.
The worker's contract category is broad. It is likely to capture many casual, zero-hours, sessional and temporary arrangements that previously sat outside the scheme because the individual was not an employee. The deciding question is whether the individual undertakes to do the work personally for someone who is not a client or customer of their own business.
The individual subcontractor category covers the self-employed tradesperson or freelancer engaged by a contractor to deliver part of a contract that the contractor has made with its own client. The contractor engaging the individual becomes the employer for Right to Work purposes and must carry out the check.
2. Arrangements That Fall Outside the Scheme
The Right to Work Scheme does not apply to people running an independent business who contract directly with their own clients. The Employer's guide illustrates the exclusion with a self-employed plumber who advertises to the public and works for many different customers, and with a graphic designer who provides services through their own personal service company, which contracts with and invoices the client. In the second example the client is contracting with a company in a business-to-business services arrangement and does not need to check the designer's Right to Work.7
The exclusion turns on the substance of the relationship rather than its label. Describing an individual as a consultant, freelancer or independent contractor will not take an arrangement outside the scheme if the individual in fact undertakes to do the work personally for a business that is not their client or customer. Equally, a genuine business-to-business contract with a company remains outside the direct checking duty, although extended liability under section 15A may still need to be considered where the company subcontracts the work.
Organisations should record the reasons for treating an engagement as outside the scheme. A documented assessment made at the start of the engagement is far easier to defend than a classification reconstructed after a Home Office visit.
3. Checking Everyone Within Scope
Every individual within scope needs a Right to Work check, whatever their nationality. British and Irish citizens have an unrestricted Right to Work, but the employer still needs a prescribed check to establish the statutory excuse. Long service, a UK accent, a local address or a previous lawful job are no substitute for the check.
Consistency also matters for discrimination law. The Home Office code on avoiding discrimination expects employers to conduct Right to Work checks in the same way on all workers, including British citizens, and to avoid checking only those who appear likely to be migrants.8 Section G explains the discrimination rules in more detail.
4. Agencies, Labour Providers and Contractual Chains
Where illegal working is found, the Home Office first looks for the employer with the direct contractual relationship with the worker.7 An employment business that engages temporary workers under contracts of employment or worker's contracts and supplies them to clients will usually be that employer and must carry out the checks itself.
Extended liability under section 15A attaches to a business that has contracted to provide or arrange work or services and passes the work down a chain. A facilities management company that subcontracts cleaning under its client contract to a labour provider, for example, can be treated as employing the labour provider's workers who do the cleaning. The Home Office will ordinarily look for the person responsible for the arrangement and consider whether it has a statutory excuse, rather than treating every party in a chain as liable. Extended liability is pursued where the direct employer cannot be identified or the prescribed requirements were not met.4
Responsibility in a chain cannot be transferred by contract alone. A clause in which a supplier warrants that its staff are entitled to work will not protect the business above it unless the prescribed contractual requirements described in Section E are in place before the work begins and operate in practice. Our guides to Right to Work checks for agency workers and labour providers and Right to Work checks for contractors and subcontractors examine these structures.
5. Online Matching Services
An online matching service has Right to Work obligations in two ways. Under section 14A it is treated as the employer of the service provider whose details it supplies to clients or customers. Under section 15A it can also be treated as employing any individual who personally does the work where a client contracts with a service provider as a result of the match.2
The statutory definition has three elements, and all three must be present. The business must keep a register of service providers, must provide an online service through which potential clients or customers can submit enquiries to be matched with them and must charge a fee or commission for making matches. A website that simply lists businesses, or a marketplace that charges a flat advertising fee without matching enquiries, may fall outside the definition, but each model needs to be assessed against the statutory wording. Our guide to Right to Work obligations for online matching platforms covers platform models in detail.
6. When the Checking Duty Applies
The date an engagement began decides which rules apply. Employment under a contract of employment is within the civil penalty scheme where it began on or after 29 February 2008. Worker's contracts, individual subcontracting arrangements and online matching services are within the scheme only where the engagement began on or after 1 October 2026.4
The extended liability requirements apply to contractual arrangements entered into on or after 1 October 2026. Businesses renewing, varying or re-tendering supply contracts after that date should treat each new arrangement as an opportunity to put the prescribed terms in place.
Business transfers raise their own timing rules. An employer acquiring staff under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 has a grace period to carry out fresh checks, but that period does not extend to individuals engaged under contracts for services. Our guide to Right to Work checks following TUPE transfers explains the rules.
Section E: The Right to Work Statutory Excuse
The Right to Work statutory excuse is the protection an organisation earns by complying with the prescribed requirements. It stands between an employer and a civil penalty if an individual turns out to be working illegally, and it is the reason the detail of each check matters so much.
Two forms of excuse now operate. The first is established through prescribed Right to Work checks and protects the direct employer. The second protects a business against extended liability under section 15A and depends on prescribed contractual terms and working controls. Our Right to Work Statutory Excuse: Employer Guide examines both in further depth.
1. What the Statutory Excuse Is
A statutory excuse is a defence against liability for a civil penalty. A direct employer establishes it by carrying out prescribed Right to Work checks before the worker starts and keeps it by completing any follow-up checks required where the worker's Right to Work is time-limited.4
The excuse operates only against the civil penalty. It gives the individual no immigration permission and it offers no defence to the criminal offence in section 21, which depends on what the employer knew or had reasonable cause to believe. An employer with a perfect paper record can still commit the offence if it continues to employ someone it knows is working illegally.
The excuse is also distinct from the individual's actual status. A person may have permission to work even though the employer never checked them properly, in which case no penalty arises because there is no illegal working, and a person may be working illegally despite a correct check, in which case the excuse protects the employer.
2. Continuous and Time-Limited Excuses
The length of the statutory excuse depends on the evidence checked. A compliant check of a List A document, such as a British passport, gives a continuous excuse for the whole of the employment. A check of a List B document gives a time-limited excuse: for List B Group 1 it lasts until the individual's permission expires, and for List B Group 2 it lasts six months from the date of a Positive Verification Notice from the Employer Checking Service.4
Online checks follow the same principle. Where the Home Office online service shows that the individual has time-limited permission, the excuse is time-limited and a follow-up check is needed on or before its expiry. Where the online service shows indefinite permission, the excuse is continuous. Pre-settled status under the EU Settlement Scheme is treated differently, since no repeat check is required after a compliant initial check.
A follow-up check must be completed on or before the date the time-limited excuse ends. A Positive Verification Notice gives a further six months, while a Negative Verification Notice ends the excuse if the employment continues. Employers should not use the Employer Checking Service where an employee has worked for them continuously since before 29 February 2008, and a Negative Verification Notice issued in that situation does not show that the individual lacks permission to work.7 Our guide to Right to Work documents: List A and List B explains which documents fall into each list.
3. When the Statutory Excuse Is Lost
The statutory excuse can be lost or never arise in several ways:
- Check not carried out as prescribed: If the check was incomplete, used an unsuitable method or omitted a required step, the employer has no excuse and remains liable if the worker is found working illegally.
- Check completed late: A check carried out after the work started gives no protection for the period before it.
- Follow-up check missed: A time-limited excuse ends on its expiry date unless a compliant follow-up check has been completed.
- Negative Verification Notice: An employer that continues to employ the individual after receiving a Negative Verification Notice has no statutory excuse. Continuous employment that began before 29 February 2008 is outside the civil penalty scheme.
- Knowledge of illegal working: Under section 15(4), the excuse does not apply where the employer knew at any time during the employment that it was contrary to section 15.
The knowledge exclusion has practical consequences. Where an employer learns, through a tip-off, a Home Office letter or its own audit, that an individual may not have the Right to Work, it should act on that information promptly. Continuing the employment while aware that the individual is working illegally removes the excuse and exposes the employer to criminal liability.7
4. The Statutory Excuse Against Extended Liability
A business facing extended liability under section 15A has a separate statutory excuse. To rely on it, the business must have a written statement of prescribed contractual terms in place before the work or services begin. The terms must cover the following matters:46
- Right to Work checks: The other party must comply with the prescribed Right to Work checking requirements for each individual who does the work, including any substitute.
- Further subcontracting: The other party must not subcontract the work without the prior written consent of the business, and any further subcontractor must also meet the checking requirements.
- Audit: The business must have the right to audit the other party's compliance with the checking and subcontracting terms whenever it requests.
- Enforcement: The contract must include enforcement provisions, such as suspension or termination, where the other party employs an individual without the Right to Work and without a statutory excuse. The other party must include equivalent enforcement provisions in its own contract with the individual worker.
- Co-operation: The other party must co-operate with any Home Office investigation, including by providing information about the contractual chain and each contracting party.
Contracts that allow an employee to send a substitute need additional controls, also in place before the work begins. The employer must check the substitute's Right to Work, cannot delegate that check to the worker and must not allow the substitute to start until the check is complete. The contract between the employer and the worker must also contain enforcement provisions, such as suspension or termination, that apply where the employer or worker knows or has reasonable cause to believe that the substitute is working illegally, or where the employer cannot complete the substitute's check because the substitute fails to co-operate.6
Identity controls apply across all three settings: contractual chains, online matching services and substitution arrangements. For the duration of the engagement, the business must maintain systems and processes, proportionate to the arrangement, to confirm that the individual doing the work is the person whose Right to Work was checked. Re-verification must take place no less than once in any 24-hour period of activity.4
The Home Office assesses extended liability case by case, including how the arrangements work in practice, and may consider whether substitution controls reflect how the work is actually carried out.4 The legislation gives the business an audit right but does not prescribe how often audits must take place. In practice, oversight proportionate to the circumstances and risk of each arrangement, with records of any audits, follow-up of concerns and enforcement action, puts a business in a far stronger position than a clause that has never been used.
5. Evidencing the Statutory Excuse
The burden of showing that a statutory excuse applies falls on the employer in practice. When the Home Office issues a penalty notice, it does not need to have established first whether the excuse applies, so the employer must produce the evidence at the objection stage.
For a direct engagement, the evidence is the retained record of the prescribed check, showing the method used, the date and the documents or online profile examined. For extended liability, the evidence is the dated written statement of contractual terms, records of any audits, correspondence with the supplier about compliance and evidence of the identity controls used for substitutes. Organisations that cannot locate this material quickly, often because it sits with a procurement team rather than HR, may be unable to rely on an excuse they in fact earned.
Section F: Civil Penalties and Criminal Liability
Civil penalties are the main enforcement tool of the illegal working regime. The Home Office issues them per illegal worker, and an employer found with several illegal workers on one visit can face a combined penalty running well into six figures. The criminal offence sits alongside the civil scheme for employers who knowingly, or with reasonable cause to believe, employ illegal workers.
A penalty also carries consequences beyond the sum payable. Licensing, sponsorship, director disqualification and public naming can all follow, and these often affect a business more than the penalty itself.
1. The Maximum Civil Penalty
The maximum civil penalty is £60,000 per illegal worker. The Immigration (Employment of Adults Subject to Immigration Control) (Maximum Penalty) (Amendment) Order 2024 (SI 2024/82) raised the maximum from £20,000 to £60,000. The increase does not apply to a penalty notice where, for every employment it covers, the contravention occurred solely before the Order came into force.10
The maximum is a ceiling. The amount in an individual case is calculated under the penalty code, which sets starting points and reductions according to the employer's history and conduct.
2. How the Penalty Is Calculated
The penalty code sets a starting amount of £45,000 per illegal worker for a first breach and £60,000 per illegal worker for a repeat breach. A breach is treated as a repeat breach where the employer has been found employing illegal workers within the previous three years.4
The starting amount can then be reduced. The code provides the following reductions, each applied per illegal worker:
- Reporting: A reduction of £5,000 where the employer reported the suspected illegal worker to the Home Office and obtained a Unique Reference Number. The reduction is available for first and repeat breaches.
- Active co-operation: A further reduction of £5,000 where the employer actively co-operated with the Home Office. The reduction is also available for first and repeat breaches.
- Warning notice: For a first breach, an employer that can show effective Right to Work practices, together with reporting and active co-operation, may receive a warning notice instead of a financial penalty. Warning notices are not available for repeat breaches.
The reductions reward conduct before and during the Home Office's involvement. An employer that discovers a possible illegal worker through its own audit and reports it promptly is in a much stronger position than one whose illegal worker is found during an enforcement visit.4
3. Paying a Civil Penalty
The penalty code offers a Faster Payment Option. An employer that pays a first penalty in full within 21 days of the penalty notice being given receives a 30% reduction. An employer that objects before the deadline in the notice remains eligible and, if a penalty is still owed after the objection, has 21 days to pay under the Faster Payment Option, where applicable, and 28 days to pay in full from the date specified in the Objection Outcome Notice. The option is not available for a repeat penalty or where the employer pays in instalments.4
An employer that cannot pay the penalty in one sum may ask to pay by instalments and must give full reasons for its inability to pay.4 A penalty that is not paid can be recovered as a debt under section 18 of the 2006 Act, and at that stage no question may be raised about liability, the excuse or the amount. Any challenge therefore needs to be made through the objection and appeal process.
4. Objecting to a Penalty Notice
An employer that disputes a penalty notice must first object to the Home Office in writing. Article 9 of the 2007 Order requires the notice of objection to be given within 28 days beginning with the date specified in the penalty notice as the date on which it is given.5 The penalty code describes the deadline as 28 days from the due date specified in the notice, which can fall later, so employers should work to the statutory deadline. The objection should include supporting evidence. The grounds of objection are that the employer is not liable, that it has a statutory excuse or that the penalty is too high because it was incorrectly calculated or did not reflect the mitigation available.4
The Home Office aims to respond within 28 days of receiving the objection, or by any later date agreed with the employer. If the employer has not received a response within 28 days of the date on which the Home Office is deemed to have received the objection, it may appeal to the court.4
The objection is often the employer's best opportunity to resolve the matter. The Home Office will look at the Right to Work records, any statutory excuse and the evidence of reporting and co-operation, so the objection should present that material in full and link each document to the ground relied on.
5. Appealing to the Court
An appeal against a civil penalty is made to the County Court in England, Wales and Northern Ireland or to the Sheriff Court in Scotland. The appeal must be brought within 28 days of the date of the Objection Outcome Notice, or of any new penalty notice issued after the objection.4 Where the employer appeals because the Home Office has not responded to the objection, the appeal period runs from a different start date under section 17 of the 2006 Act, and an employer that has agreed an extension with the Home Office should confirm how it affects its appeal deadline before relying on it.
The appeal is a re-hearing and is limited to the same grounds as an objection. The court must consider the penalty code when deciding the amount and may order costs against an unsuccessful employer.4
6. The Criminal Offence of Employing an Illegal Worker
Section 21 of the 2006 Act creates two criminal offences. Under section 21(1), a person commits an offence if they employ someone knowing that the employee is disqualified from employment by reason of their immigration status. Under section 21(1A), a person commits an offence if they employ someone having reasonable cause to believe that the employee is disqualified.
The offence is triable either way. On conviction on indictment, the maximum sentence is five years' imprisonment, a fine or both, and a lower maximum applies on summary conviction.1 The statutory excuse in section 15 offers no defence, since the offence turns on the employer's knowledge or reasonable cause to believe.
Section 22 extends the offence to organisations and the people who run them. A body, whether incorporated or not, is treated as knowing a fact, or as having reasonable cause to believe it, if a person with responsibility within the body for an aspect of the employment knows or has reasonable cause to believe that fact. Where a body corporate commits the offence with the consent or connivance of an officer, such as a director, manager or secretary, the officer is also treated as having committed it. Equivalent provision applies to partners in a partnership.1
7. Wider Consequences of Illegal Working
A civil penalty or prosecution can trigger further consequences. The penalty code lists the following:4
- Home Office records: The penalty is recorded on Home Office systems and may be taken into account in future immigration applications.
- Business closure: The business may be closed and made subject to a compliance order issued by a court.
- Director disqualification: Directors may face disqualification proceedings.
- Sponsorship: The employer may be unable to sponsor migrant workers, and an existing sponsor licence may be reviewed.
- Earnings: Earnings derived from illegal working may be seized.
- Licences: Alcohol, late-night refreshment, private hire and taxi licences may be reviewed or revoked.
- Publication: The Home Office may publish details of non-compliant employers on GOV.UK.
For many organisations the loss of a sponsor licence is the most damaging of these outcomes, since it can leave sponsored workers without permission to continue in their roles. Our Right to Work Compliance Audits guide explains how to identify and correct weaknesses before an enforcement visit.
Section G: Right to Work Checks and Discrimination
Right to Work checks and discrimination law overlap at every stage of recruitment and engagement. An employer that checks only the people it assumes are migrants, or that treats an applicant less favourably because of how they prove their status, risks a claim for unlawful discrimination even if it avoids a civil penalty.
The legal duty to prevent illegal working and the duty not to discriminate therefore need to be met together. Our Right to Work Checks and Discrimination guide covers the issues in more depth.
1. The Legal Basis
The Equality Act 2010 prohibits discrimination in recruitment and employment because of protected characteristics, including race, which covers colour, nationality and ethnic or national origins.11 Equivalent legislation applies in Northern Ireland.
Section 23 of the 2006 Act requires the Secretary of State to issue a code of practice on what employers should and should not do to avoid unlawful discrimination while meeting their Right to Work obligations. The current code, in force from 1 October 2026, aims to ensure that employers do not discriminate contrary to the Equality Act 2010 or the relevant Northern Ireland legislation when carrying out Right to Work checks. It also applies to employment and recruitment agencies where they are employers, and those agencies have separate statutory obligations under the 2010 Act.8
2. Applying Checks Consistently
The discrimination code sets out what employers should and should not do. Employers should:
- conduct Right to Work checks consistently on all workers, including British citizens
- make job selections on the basis of suitability for the post
- ensure that no prospective applicants are discouraged or excluded, directly or indirectly, because of known or perceived protected characteristics.
Employers should not discriminate when conducting Right to Work checks, check only the status of those who appear likely to be migrants or make assumptions about an individual's Right to Work or immigration status based on characteristics such as race, nationality or accent.7
A consistent procedure is the most reliable protection. Where every candidate who reaches the same stage is asked to prove their Right to Work in the same way and at the same point, the employer is well placed to show that its process did not single anyone out.
3. Choice of Checking Method
An employer cannot insist on a particular checking method. The individual chooses how to prove their Right to Work from the prescribed methods available in their circumstances, and the employer must give a reasonable opportunity to do so. An individual who does not want to use a digital check should be offered another route, such as a manual check, where that route is available to them.7 A requirement to use a digital identity check, or a refusal to accept a manual check of a British passport, can disadvantage people who do not have access to the relevant technology or documents.
The same principle applies to individuals whose status is held digitally. A person with an eVisa will usually prove their Right to Work through the Home Office online service, and the employer should not ask for physical documents instead. A person with an outstanding application who cannot provide a share code may need the employer to use the Employer Checking Service, and an employer should not reject such an applicant simply because the process takes longer than a document check.
4. Liability for Discrimination by Staff and Providers
An employer is liable for discriminatory acts carried out by its staff in the course of their employment. It can avoid that liability if it proves that it took all reasonable steps to prevent the discrimination, and the code gives training staff on how to carry out Right to Work checks without discriminating as an example of such a step.8
Using an RtW DVSP or another third party for part of the process leaves the employer responsible for the outcome. Organisations should check that a provider's process offers alternatives for people who cannot complete a digital check and does not produce different results for different groups of applicants.
Retrospective checks need particular care. Where an employer carries out checks on existing staff, for example after an audit, it must do so in a non-discriminatory manner and in line with the discrimination code.7 Checking only staff of a particular nationality, or only those recruited through a particular route, is likely to be discriminatory.
Section H: Right to Work Employer Obligations FAQs
What are an employer's Right to Work obligations in the UK?
An employer's Right to Work obligations are the duties imposed by the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 to prevent illegal working. The employer must check that each person within scope may do the work offered, using a prescribed method before the work starts, repeat the check where time-limited permission requires it, keep records for the employment plus two years and carry out checks without unlawful discrimination.
Is a Right to Work check a legal requirement?
A Right to Work check is the step the law requires an employer to take to protect itself against a civil penalty. The 2006 Act imposes liability for employing an illegal worker and gives a statutory excuse only to employers that complete the prescribed checks. The Home Office treats preventing illegal working as a legal duty on all UK employers.
Who must carry out Right to Work checks after October 2026?
Right to Work checks must be carried out by anyone who employs an individual under a contract of employment or a worker's contract, engages an individual subcontractor or operates an online matching service. Businesses higher up a contractual chain, online matching services and employers whose contracts allow substitution can also face extended liability unless they have the prescribed contractual terms and controls in place.
Do employers need to check British citizens?
British citizens need a Right to Work check in the same way as anyone else within scope. Their Right to Work is unrestricted, but the employer needs a prescribed check to establish a statutory excuse, and checking all workers consistently helps the employer avoid discrimination claims.
Does a Right to Work check apply to self-employed contractors?
A Right to Work check is needed for a self-employed individual where the arrangement is a worker's contract or an individual subcontracting arrangement within the 2006 Act. People running an independent business who contract directly with their own clients, and companies providing services business to business, fall outside the direct checking duty.
What is the penalty for employing an illegal worker?
The penalty for employing an illegal worker is a civil penalty of up to £60,000 per worker. The Home Office starts at £45,000 per worker for a first breach and £60,000 for a repeat breach within three years, before reductions for reporting and co-operation. Knowingly employing an illegal worker, or doing so with reasonable cause to believe, is also a criminal offence carrying up to five years' imprisonment.
Can an employer challenge a civil penalty?
An employer can challenge a civil penalty by objecting in writing to the Home Office within 28 days beginning with the date the penalty notice states it was given. If the objection fails or receives no response within 28 days, the employer can appeal to the County Court or, in Scotland, the Sheriff Court within the time limit set by the penalty code.
Does a statutory excuse protect directors from prosecution?
A statutory excuse protects the employer against a civil penalty only. The criminal offence depends on knowledge or reasonable cause to believe, and a director, manager or secretary can be prosecuted personally where a company commits the offence with their consent or connivance.
Can an employer refuse an applicant who cannot use a digital Right to Work check?
An employer should not refuse an applicant because they cannot or will not use a digital Right to Work check. The individual chooses how to prove their Right to Work from the prescribed methods available to them, and refusing a permitted alternative risks unlawful discrimination.
Section I: Glossary
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Right to Work Scheme | The statutory scheme in sections 14A to 25 of the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 under which organisations face civil penalties for illegal working and can establish a statutory excuse through prescribed checks. |
| Prescribed Requirements | The checking steps and contractual requirements set out in the Immigration (Restrictions on Employment) Order 2007, as amended, which an organisation must meet to establish a statutory excuse. |
| Statutory Excuse | A defence against liability for a civil penalty, established by completing prescribed Right to Work checks or, for extended liability, by having prescribed contractual terms and controls in place before work begins. |
| Continuous Statutory Excuse | A statutory excuse that lasts for the whole of the employment, usually following a compliant check of a List A document or of indefinite permission through the Home Office online service. |
| Time-Limited Statutory Excuse | A statutory excuse that ends on a set date, following a check of time-limited permission or a Positive Verification Notice, and must be renewed through a follow-up check. Holders of EUSS pre-settled status need no repeat check. |
| Worker's Contract | A contract, other than a contract of employment or apprenticeship, under which an individual personally does work or services for another person who is not a client or customer of the individual's own profession or business. |
| Individual Subcontractor | An individual who contracts to provide work or services that the other party has itself contracted with a third party to provide or arrange, where the individual has no contract with the third party. |
| Online Matching Service | A business that keeps a register of service providers, runs an online service for clients or customers to submit enquiries to be matched with them and charges a fee or commission for making matches. |
| Extended Liability | Civil penalty liability under section 15A of the 2006 Act for a business that is treated as employing an individual further down a contractual chain, matched through an online service or working as a substitute. |
| Substitution Clause | A contractual term allowing the engaged individual to send another person to do the work in their place, which triggers additional Right to Work controls under the extended liability provisions. |
| Civil Penalty | A financial penalty of up to £60,000 per illegal worker that the Home Office may impose under section 15 of the 2006 Act. |
| Repeat Breach | A breach where the employer has been found employing illegal workers within the previous three years, attracting a higher starting penalty. |
| Warning Notice | A notice issued instead of a financial penalty for a first breach where the employer shows effective Right to Work practices and has reported and co-operated. |
| Faster Payment Option | A 30% reduction available where a first civil penalty is paid in full within 21 days of the penalty notice being given or, after an objection, of the date specified in the Objection Outcome Notice. |
| Objection Outcome Notice | The Home Office's written decision on an employer's objection to a penalty notice, from which the 28-day time limit for an appeal runs. |
| Positive Verification Notice | Confirmation from the Employer Checking Service that an individual has the right to do the work in question, giving a time-limited statutory excuse of six months. |
| Negative Verification Notice | Confirmation from the Employer Checking Service that an individual does not have the right to do the work in question, ending any statutory excuse if the employment continues. A notice issued for continuous employment that began before 29 February 2008 does not carry that meaning. |
| RtW DVSP | A Right to Work digital verification service provider registered to carry out digital identity checks for Right to Work purposes. |
Section J: Official Sources
| Description | URL |
|---|---|
| 1. Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006, sections 14A to 25 (as amended) - legislation.gov.uk, latest available (revised) version. Check the "Changes to legislation" panel, as some amendments may not yet be incorporated into the revised text. | https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/13/contents |
| 2. Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025, section 48 - Inserts sections 14A and 15A into the 2006 Act. In force 1 October 2026. | https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2025/31/section/48 |
| 3. The Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 (Commencement No. 4) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/683) - Brings section 48 of the 2025 Act into force on 1 October 2026. | https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2026/683/made |
| 4. Home Office, Code of practice on preventing illegal working: Right to Work Scheme for employers - Seventh version, dated 1 October 2026, issued under section 19 of the 2006 Act. In force 1 October 2026; replaces the January 2024 version. | https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abe1532943e890cb55e5d97/Code_of_practice_on_preventing_illegal_working_-_Right_to_Work_Scheme_for_employers.pdf |
| 5. The Immigration (Restrictions on Employment) Order 2007 (SI 2007/3290) - Prescribed requirements for establishing a statutory excuse, as amended. Article 9 prescribes the period for giving a notice of objection. | https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2007/3290/contents |
| 6. The Immigration (Restrictions on Employment and Residential Accommodation) (Prescribed Requirements and Codes of Practice) (Amendment) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/700) - Made 24 June 2026, laid 30 June 2026, in force 1 October 2026. Inserts article 5B into the 2007 Order. | https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2026/700/made |
| 7. Home Office, Employer's guide to Right to Work checks - Version published and in force 1 October 2026, updating the version of 16 July 2026. | https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/right-to-work-checks-employers-guide |
| 8. Home Office, Code of practice for employers: avoiding unlawful discrimination while preventing illegal working - October 2026 version, issued under section 23 of the 2006 Act. In force 1 October 2026. | https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/right-to-work-checks-code-of-practice-on-avoiding-discrimination |
| 9. Home Office, Workers and Temporary Workers: guidance for sponsors, Appendix D: record-keeping duties - Version 10/26, published 8 October 2026. | https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6ac62285e635a394acb92387/Sponsor-guidance-Appendix-D-10-26-v1.0__1_.pdf |
| 10. The Immigration (Employment of Adults Subject to Immigration Control) (Maximum Penalty) (Amendment) Order 2024 (SI 2024/82) - Made 23 January 2024. Raises the maximum civil penalty to £60,000 per illegal worker. | https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2024/82/made |
| 11. Equality Act 2010 - legislation.gov.uk, latest available (revised) version. | https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/contents |
Legal Disclaimer
The matters contained in this article are intended to be for general information purposes only. This article does not constitute legal advice, nor is it a complete or authoritative statement of the law, and should not be treated as such. Whilst every effort is made to ensure that the information is correct at the time of writing, no warranty, express or implied, is given as to its accuracy and no liability is accepted for any error or omission. Before acting on any of the information contained herein, expert legal advice should be sought.