20 November 2026

Who Needs a Right to Work Check? UK Employer Guide 2026

Picture of Anne Morris

Anne Morris

Business Immigration & Workforce Compliance Solicitor

Section Guide

A Right to Work check is needed for every adult a business employs or engages to work in the UK under a covered arrangement, and since 1 October 2026 those arrangements include worker’s contracts, individual sub-contractors and online matching services as well as employment.

Getting the answer to who needs a Right to Work check wrong can leave a business facing a civil penalty that starts at £45,000 per illegal worker, and extended liability can reach businesses with no direct contract with the person doing the work.

This guide explains which working arrangements are covered, which organisation must carry out the check and what each party needs in place before work begins.

Key Takeaways

  • Every adult employed or engaged to work in the UK under a covered arrangement needs a Right to Work check, whatever their nationality.
  • Worker’s contracts, individual sub-contractors and online matching services have been covered since 1 October 2026.
  • Businesses that subcontract work they have contracted to provide can face extended liability.
  • End users buying work or services for their own operations fall outside extended liability.
  • Civil penalties start at £45,000 per illegal worker for a first breach.

SECTION GUIDE

Who Needs a Right to Work Check: At a Glance

Right to Work checks were long treated as an HR task tied to the contract of employment. From 1 October 2026 the illegal working rules in the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 also reach people engaged under a worker’s contract, individual sub-contractors and service providers found through online matching platforms. A business that has contracted to supply work to a client and passes it down a chain can be treated as the employer of whoever turns up to do it, and its statutory excuse then depends on having the prescribed written statement and identity controls in place before work starts, together with substitute checks where substitution is allowed. British and Irish citizens need checks too, and labels such as self-employed or agency worker settle nothing on their own. Some people fall outside the scheme, including genuine volunteers, independent businesses serving their own clients and anyone working wholly overseas. The sections below take each category in turn, explain who carries the checking responsibility and set out the timing rules, including how contracts signed before 1 October 2026 are treated.

 

Section A: Who Needs a Right to Work Check?

 

A Right to Work check is needed for every adult an organisation employs or engages to work in the UK under a covered arrangement if the organisation wants a statutory excuse against a civil penalty for illegal working. Since 1 October 2026 the question reaches well beyond conventional employees. Section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 inserted sections 14A and 15A into the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 (the 2006 Act), so the illegal working provisions now also cover people engaged under a worker’s contract, individual sub-contractors and online matching services, and can extend liability to businesses further up a chain of contracts.

The starting point for any business is to identify who is actually doing the work, the legal nature of the engagement and which organisation or organisations carry responsibility under the 2006 Act.

The 2006 Act allows the Home Office to impose a civil penalty on an employer that employs an adult subject to immigration control who has no permission to do the work in question. The extended meaning of employment applies across sections 15 to 24 of the Act, so it reaches the criminal offence in section 21 of employing an illegal worker knowing, or having reasonable cause to believe, that they are disqualified, as well as the civil penalty scheme.

Civil penalties for illegal working are calculated from a starting point of £45,000 per illegal worker for a first breach and £60,000 for a repeat breach, before any reductions, under the current code of practice. A breach counts as a repeat where the employer has received a civil penalty notice or warning notice, or committed the section 21 offence, in the previous three years. A conviction for the section 21 offence can lead to up to five years in prison and an unlimited fine. Our guide to Right to Work civil penalties explains how penalties are calculated, reduced and challenged.

Whether an individual has permission to do the work is a separate question from what the organisation must do to secure a statutory excuse, and both are separate again from any sponsor licence duties. An organisation may be directly responsible for a prescribed check, potentially liable through a contractual chain or bound by sponsor duties, and in some arrangements all three apply at once.

The answer in each case turns on the substance of the working arrangement and the statutory definitions, so labels such as self-employed, agency worker or subcontractor settle nothing on their own.

 

1. Who Must Be Checked?

 

Right to Work checks apply to everyone within the statutory regime, whatever their nationality. The regime concerns adults, meaning people aged 16 or over. The Employer’s guide applies the civil penalty to breaches involving people aged 16 and over, and Home Office sponsor guidance confirms that workers under 16 are not subject to statutory Right to Work checks.

In conventional employment the requirement covers British citizens, Irish citizens and people with immigration permission alike. Employers should run the same checking process for every prospective employee and should never select people for checks because of their appearance, accent, name or perceived nationality.

The expanded regime adds specified non-employee arrangements where the statutory conditions are met. The main categories to consider are:

 

  • Individuals employed under contracts of employment.
  • Individuals engaged under a worker’s contract to do work or services personally for a party that is not their client or customer.
  • Individual sub-contractors engaged to provide work or services that the engaging business has itself contracted to provide to a third party.
  • Service providers matched with clients or customers through an online matching service.
  • Individuals whose work may expose another organisation to extended civil penalty liability under section 15A of the 2006 Act.

 

Each category rests on its own statutory provision, and that provision decides both whether the individual is in scope and which organisation may be liable. The category has to be settled first, because the checking procedure or statutory excuse follows from it.

For an explanation of the prescribed methods, see our guide to Right to Work checks.

 

2. Direct Checking Responsibility and Extended Liability

 

The organisation that engages an individual directly may not be the only business exposed to liability for illegal working.

Section 15A of the 2006 Act applies where a business has contracted to provide or arrange work or services and subcontracts all or part of that work. The business is then treated as employing anyone who personally does the work, even without a direct contract with that person or any knowledge of their involvement, and wherever its own contract sits in the chain. Section 15A also catches an online matching service where a service provider it has matched goes on to contract with a client. The liability of the direct employer is unaffected.

Extended liability is aimed at businesses that supply work or services to others. Home Office guidance states that extended liability does not apply to a client, customer or end user buying work or services for its own internal operations, such as a retailer buying cleaning services for its own premises. Where extended liability does apply, the guidance describes the Home Office pursuing an organisation further up the chain where the direct employer cannot be identified and the prescribed requirements have not been met, and states that it would not normally expect to issue a civil penalty notice to more than one employer for the same worker.

Responsibility for carrying out a prescribed Right to Work check therefore needs to be kept apart from potential liability arising from another organisation’s engagement of an individual. The distinction comes up most often with recruitment agencies, contractors and subcontractors.

Exposure to extended liability does not oblige a business to repeat every check another party has carried out. The business needs to establish which provisions apply and whether it can meet the prescribed requirements for a statutory excuse. Depending on the arrangement, those requirements can include prescribed contractual terms set out in a written statement, controls over further subcontracting, procedures for checking substitutes and practical identity verification. Ordinary commercial assurances and indemnities are a different thing and do not meet them.

The working arrangement, the organisations with statutory responsibilities and the checking procedures all need to be settled before the relevant work begins.

For further guidance on the legal protection available to employers, see Right to Work statutory excuse.

 

3. The Importance of Establishing Checking Scope

 

A business that misclassifies an engagement may skip a check the regime requires or overlook liability arising through another organisation.

Calling someone an independent contractor does not take the engagement outside the expanded framework. The contractual terms, any obligation of personal service and the nature of the relationship all have to be considered. Home Office guidance adds that an assessment of employment status for employment-law purposes cannot automatically decide whether a check is required, and that IR35 status does not determine checking responsibilities.

Having no direct contract with the individual can still leave a business in a subcontracting chain with statutory responsibilities.

Misallocated responsibility also creates practical gaps. One organisation assumes another has completed the checks, and neither has confirmed that the prescribed requirements were met.

Checking scope is best settled when the engagement is planned, long before any compliance concern or Home Office investigation arises. The assessment belongs in recruitment, procurement, labour supply and contractor onboarding.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section B: Which Categories of Workers Must Be Checked?

 

The statutory Right to Work regime applies to several categories of working arrangement, and the correct category depends on the actual contractual relationship and the statutory definitions. The labels used in contracts, payroll records or procurement documents do not determine whether a check is required.

 

1. Employees Under Contracts of Employment

 

Individuals employed under a contract of employment fall within the established checking framework. The category covers permanent, fixed-term and temporary employees, together with casual or variable-hours staff wherever a contract of employment exists.

The employer should establish the individual’s right to do the proposed work before employment begins, using the prescribed check that applies to them. The requirement applies equally to British citizens, Irish citizens and people subject to immigration control.

Previous work in the UK, a National Insurance number or past employment with another organisation does not exempt anyone from a check.

Long-serving employees whose employment with the same employer began before 29 February 2008 and has continued without a break fall outside the civil penalty scheme.

Where an individual’s permission to work is time-limited, the employer may also need a follow-up check to keep the statutory excuse in place. See follow-up Right to Work checks for further guidance.

 

2. Temporary, Casual and Zero-Hours Workers

 

Temporary, casual and zero-hours arrangements sit within the checking requirements in the same way as any other engagement. Where the individual has a contract of employment, the ordinary employer obligations apply. Where they are not an employee, the organisation should assess whether the arrangement is a worker’s contract or falls within another category brought in on 1 October 2026.

How often someone works, the absence of guaranteed hours and the short length of an assignment do not, by themselves, decide whether a prescribed check is required. Businesses using seasonal workers, temporary labour or people engaged for occasional assignments should settle the contractual category before the work begins.

 

3. Individuals Working Under Qualifying Worker Contracts

 

Section 14A of the 2006 Act brings the worker’s contract within the illegal working provisions. A worker’s contract is a contract, other than a contract of service or apprenticeship, under which an individual undertakes to do work or services personally for another party that is not a client or customer of a profession or business undertaking carried on by the individual. The contract can be express or implied and, where express, oral or in writing.

The definition reaches many arrangements that are not contracts of employment. Businesses should consider whether the individual has undertaken to do the work personally, whether the arrangement fits the statutory definition and whether the client or customer exception applies.

The exception covers genuine business-to-client relationships, where the engaging party is a client or customer of the individual’s own profession or business. Describing someone as self-employed or a consultant does not establish that the exception applies. The actual relationship, the contractual obligations and the circumstances in which the work is done are what count.

Where a worker’s contract exists, the engaging organisation should identify the Right to Work requirements and statutory excuse provisions that apply to it.

 

4. Individual Subcontractors

 

Individual sub-contractors are the second category added by section 14A. An individual sub-contractor is an individual who contracts with a business to provide work or services that the business has itself contracted to provide to a third party.

An individual sub-contractor needs to be distinguished from an independent business supplying services through its own employees or workforce. Issuing invoices, trading as a sole trader or being called a subcontractor does not decide the statutory position. The organisation should examine the contractual chain, identify the person actually doing the work and check whether the statutory conditions are met.

Where an individual sub-contractor falls within section 14A, the business that engages them directly has statutory responsibilities. Organisations further up the chain may need to consider extended liability under section 15A where they too have contracted to provide the work or services to someone else.

For a more detailed treatment of contractor arrangements, see Right to Work checks for contractors.

 

5. Workers Using Online Matching Services

 

Online matching services are the third category added on 1 October 2026. The statutory definition covers registers and platforms operated as a business that match service providers, meaning people providing or seeking to provide work or services for remuneration, with clients or customers. A matching service falls within section 14A, and is treated as the employer, when it supplies a service provider’s details to potential clients or customers.

A platform stays within the regime even if it calls itself an intermediary or employs none of the people who use it. Equally, not every website, online directory or digital marketplace is an online matching service for these purposes. The nature of the service, the contractual arrangements and the statutory criteria decide the position.

Section 15A adds a second route to liability. Where a service provider matched through the platform goes on to contract with a client, the matching service can be treated as employing the person who does the work, even though there is no conventional employment relationship.

Operators should identify their statutory responsibilities and the prescribed requirements for a statutory excuse. Home Office guidance places matching services on the article 5B route, which requires a written statement in place before the work or service starts together with substitution controls and identity verification, and it does not require the operator to carry out the prescribed check on each service provider itself.

See Right to Work rules for UK gig employers for further guidance.

 

6. Sponsored Migrant Workers

 

Licensed sponsors must carry out and keep evidence of Right to Work checks on any worker they sponsor, regardless of the nature of the working arrangement, and on any worker they employ or are treated as employing under the statutory scheme. The duty is set out in Appendix D of the sponsor guidance (version 10/26, valid from 8 October 2026), which also requires the check to be made before the worker starts working for the sponsor.

Where the sponsor is the employer, or is treated as the employer, the one check serves both sponsor compliance and the statutory excuse. Where the sponsor does not need a statutory excuse, Appendix D still requires the check for its sponsor duties.

The two regimes remain separate. The civil penalty provisions decide when an organisation is liable for illegal working and what it must do to secure a statutory excuse. Sponsor duties add requirements about the sponsored worker’s immigration status, permitted duties, monitoring and record-keeping, and a sponsor can face compliance consequences even where no civil penalty arises.

 

7. Sponsored Workers Engaged by Another Organisation

 

Some sponsored workers are employed or engaged by an organisation other than the licensed sponsor, where the sponsorship rules permit the arrangement. Appendix D states that the other organisation is normally responsible for carrying out the Right to Work check. The sponsor must then either obtain and retain evidence of that check or carry out its own separate check.

The other organisation’s responsibility for the statutory check leaves the sponsor’s record-keeping duty in place. Sponsors should agree in advance how evidence of the check will be obtained, verified and retained.

The arrangement itself must also be permitted under the sponsorship rules. Permission to do particular work does not mean every deployment or contractual structure is allowed under the sponsor licence regime. Where a sponsored worker’s duties, work location, employing organisation or contractual arrangements change, the sponsor should consider whether reporting, record-keeping or other sponsor duties are triggered.

For further guidance, see sponsor compliance.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section C: Do British and Irish Citizens Need Right to Work Checks?

 

British and Irish citizens need Right to Work checks in the same way as every other prospective employee, using the prescribed method that applies to them. Home Office guidance asks employers to be consistent in how they check all workers and warns against checking only those they consider more likely to be migrants.

British and Irish citizens generally have an unrestricted Right to Work in the UK. An employer that wants a statutory excuse against a civil penalty still has to establish that entitlement through a prescribed check, because the excuse comes from the check and the individual’s underlying status does not supply it.

 

1. British Citizens

 

British citizens generally have the right of abode in the UK and face no immigration restrictions on their employment. The employer should still carry out the prescribed Right to Work check before employment begins.

A manual check can rely on a British passport, current or expired, or on a UK birth or adoption certificate produced together with an official document showing the person’s name and permanent National Insurance number. A clipped passport is a cancelled document and cannot be accepted.

Employers can also use a registered Right to Work digital verification service provider (RtW DVSP) to check a British passport digitally. The provider must appear on the digital verification services register, and it can verify expired British or Irish passports up to six months past expiry using passive authentication. Employers cannot insist that an individual uses a digital check and should offer a manual check as an alternative.

A British-sounding name, a UK address, a National Insurance number or a previous employment history does not establish a statutory excuse. The evidence has to meet the prescribed requirements.

 

2. Irish Citizens

 

Irish citizens generally have the right to live and work in the UK under the Common Travel Area arrangements and do not ordinarily need immigration permission to take up employment.

Employers should still complete the prescribed Right to Work check before employment begins. An Irish passport or Irish passport card, current or expired, is acceptable for a manual check, and an RtW DVSP can check an Irish passport digitally. Most Irish citizens do not hold an eVisa. Irish citizens who hold a frontier worker permit have a digital permit, and employers should check their Right to Work through the Home Office online service in the usual way.

The employer should retain the evidence in line with the statutory record-keeping requirements.

 

3. Avoiding Discriminatory Checking Practices

 

Right to Work checks should be applied consistently to every prospective employee, whatever their nationality, ethnic origin or perceived immigration status. Home Office guidance states that it is unlawful to discriminate against individuals on grounds of protected characteristics. The relevant legislation is the Equality Act 2010 in Great Britain, with separate legislation in Northern Ireland.

Checking only people who appear to be foreign nationals, or asking particular groups for extra evidence without a legal basis, creates discrimination risk. The Home Office strongly recommends that employers refer to its Code of Practice for employers: Avoiding unlawful discrimination while preventing illegal working.

Recruitment teams need to know the difference between choosing the correct prescribed method for an individual’s circumstances and selecting individuals for checks on discriminatory grounds.

For further guidance, see discrimination and Right to Work checks.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section D: Who May Fall Outside the Statutory Right to Work Requirements?

 

Some people who do things for a business fall outside the statutory Right to Work checking regime. The position depends on whether the arrangement meets a statutory definition: a contract of employment, a worker’s contract, an individual sub-contractor arrangement or an online matching service.

Falling outside the civil penalty framework is a different matter from being permitted to do the activity under immigration law. An individual may be outside the checking regime and still be barred from the work by the conditions of their permission.

Being unpaid, described as self-employed or engaged through another business does not by itself place someone in an excluded category.

 

1. Genuine Volunteers

 

Genuine volunteers can fall outside the statutory checking regime where there is no contract of employment and no other covered arrangement. Home Office guidance describes a volunteer as someone who gives their time freely, with no contract and no pay apart from limited expenses.

The guidance states that a volunteer is not the same as a voluntary worker. A voluntary worker is under a contractual obligation to perform work, and only certain organisations can use voluntary workers. Any other work requires permission even when it is unpaid.

Someone called a volunteer may in fact work under arrangements that create enforceable obligations or meet another statutory definition. Organisations should look at the substance of the arrangement, including whether the individual must perform work, whether the organisation must provide it and whether payments or benefits are given beyond limited expenses.

Where the individual holds immigration permission, the organisation should also check that the activity is allowed under its conditions. Students who are not permitted to work, for example, cannot do voluntary work. The absence of wages does not show that no immigration compliance issue arises.

 

2. Genuine Independent Businesses and Professional Services

 

Genuine independent businesses fall outside the worker’s contract definition where the engaging party is a client or customer of a profession or business undertaking carried on by the individual. Home Office guidance states that it does not apply to individuals operating an independent business in their own name or through their own company, or to services provided directly to members of the public.

The guidance illustrates the point with a self-employed plumber, for whom a Right to Work check is not required, and a designer working through a personal service company, whom the client company does not need to check.

Registration as self-employed, invoicing or responsibility for one’s own tax affairs does not by itself show that the exception applies. As noted in Section A, tax and employment-law status do not decide the immigration position. Businesses should look at the actual contractual relationship, including whether the individual must do the work personally and whether the recipient is genuinely a client or customer of the individual’s own business.

The exception cannot be used as a blanket reason to exclude contractors from Right to Work procedures. Where the arrangement involves subcontracting or another organisation arranging the work, separate statutory provisions may also apply.

 

3. Individuals Working Entirely Outside the UK

 

The statutory Right to Work scheme covers only work or services carried out in the UK. Home Office guidance states that work performed wholly overseas does not fall within scope, even where a UK-based organisation engages the individual.

Where the individual carries out duties in the UK, travels to the UK for work or splits their activities between the UK and another country, the UK work needs to be assessed separately. The individual’s nationality, place of residence and contractual employer do not, by themselves, decide whether UK immigration restrictions apply to work done physically in the UK.

Businesses should also consider the immigration and employment requirements of the country where the individual works. Where overseas personnel visit the UK, the organisation should establish whether their planned activities are permitted under the relevant immigration route.

 

4. Officeholders and Non-Executive Directors

 

Officeholders and non-executive directors are assessed against the same statutory definitions as anyone else, since Home Office guidance does not treat directors as a separate category. Holding a corporate office does not, by itself, create a contract of employment.

A non-executive director who acts solely as an officeholder, with no contract of employment, worker’s contract or other covered arrangement, may fall outside the checking regime. Many directors also have employment contracts, service agreements or other arrangements for personal work or services, and where they do, the statutory requirements must be assessed for that arrangement.

The legal status of the office therefore needs to be kept apart from any separate contractual obligations the individual has taken on. Companies should also confirm that a director who is subject to immigration control has permission to carry out the proposed activities.

 

5. Unpaid Interns, Work Experience and Trial Shifts

 

Unpaid interns, work experience participants and people doing trial shifts need careful assessment, because an absence of pay does not settle whether they fall within the statutory regime. Home Office guidance does not address these arrangements directly, so the answer comes from the statutory definitions.

A contract of employment or a worker’s contract can be express or implied, and an express contract can be oral. An unpaid internship, placement or trial shift may therefore involve obligations to perform work that bring it within a covered category. The question is whether the arrangement is genuinely observational or whether the individual is doing productive work under a contractual obligation, and the label the organisation uses is not conclusive.

A short trial shift is not exempt merely because no permanent position has yet been offered. Where a covered engagement exists, the prescribed checks should be completed before the individual starts.

Immigration conditions need checking too. Students may undertake work placements that are integral to and assessed as part of their course, within the limits of their permission, while other unpaid work may still require permission.

 

6. Why Statutory Exclusion Does Not Eliminate Immigration Risk

 

An arrangement that falls outside a statutory Right to Work definition can still raise immigration compliance concerns.

An individual may be doing something their immigration conditions prohibit even where the organisation faces no civil penalty under the employment provisions. Licensed sponsors may also have separate duties about sponsored workers and their permitted activities.

The civil penalty framework sits alongside wider immigration compliance obligations, including sponsor duties and the limits on activities permitted under particular immigration routes. Where the contractual position is uncertain, the organisation should assess the actual working arrangement before concluding that no check or other compliance step is needed.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section E: Who Is Responsible for Carrying Out Right to Work Checks?

 

Responsibility for Right to Work checks depends on the working arrangement and the statutory provisions that apply to it. In conventional employment, the employer secures the statutory excuse by carrying out the prescribed check. Since 1 October 2026, organisations also need to consider worker’s contracts, individual sub-contractors, online matching services and extended liability through contractual chains.

A clause in a commercial agreement cannot move checking responsibility from one party to another. Equally, exposure to extended liability does not require every organisation in a chain to repeat the same check, because the statutory excuse for extended liability rests on separate prescribed safeguards with their own conditions.

 

1. Direct Employers

 

Direct employers are responsible for carrying out the prescribed Right to Work check on anyone they employ under a contract of employment if they want a statutory excuse against a civil penalty. The check must be completed before employment begins, using the method prescribed for the individual’s circumstances.

A check completed by a previous employer does not give a new employer a statutory excuse for its own employment relationship. Where recruitment is outsourced, the employer keeps the statutory responsibility and should make sure that the prescribed requirements are met and the evidence is available to it.

For further guidance, see Right to Work check requirements.

 

2. Recruitment Agencies and Labour Providers

 

Recruitment agencies and labour providers engage people under different contractual structures. In some arrangements the agency engages the individual and supplies their services to a hirer. In others the agency introduces a candidate whom the end user then engages directly. Some arrangements involve a worker’s contract or subcontracting that falls within the expanded framework. The actual contracts decide where responsibility sits.

Where the agency engages and supplies the worker, Home Office guidance treats the agency as the employer and states that it is responsible for conducting the Right to Work check. The guidance adds that the changes are not intended to require routine duplication of these checks by the hirer.

Where the end user employs the individual or engages them under a worker’s contract, the end user carries its own checking responsibility.

Extended liability under section 15A does not apply to a client, customer or end user buying work or services for its own internal operations. A business that obtains agency labour to run its own premises is in that position. The position changes where the business has itself contracted to provide work or services to a third party and uses agency labour to deliver them. In that case section 15A may apply, and the business will need the prescribed safeguards described below, including a written statement with the agency. A general assurance from the agency that all workers have permission to work does not meet those requirements.

For more information, see Right to Work checks for agency workers.

 

3. Contractors and Subcontracting Businesses

 

Contractor arrangements often involve several organisations with different roles. A business may contract with a service provider, which appoints a subcontractor, which in turn engages an individual to do the work.

The party that engages the individual directly must assess whether the individual falls within a covered statutory category and, if so, carry out the prescribed check. Other organisations in the chain need to consider section 15A where they have contracted to provide the work or services to someone else. Having no direct contract with the individual does not prevent liability, but a subcontracting relationship does not make every party liable either, since the statutory conditions must be met.

Businesses should map the chain, identify which party engages the individual and assess which other parties may be treated as employers for civil penalty purposes. Where the extended liability statutory excuse applies, the business needs the written statement terms and practical safeguards set out later in this section, together with a reliable way of verifying the identity of the individuals doing the work. Ordinary warranties and indemnities do not satisfy those requirements.

For further guidance, see Right to Work checks for contractors.

 

4. Online Matching Services

 

Operators of online matching services have statutory responsibilities even though they do not directly employ the service providers who use the platform. As Section B explains, a matching service falls within section 14A, and is treated as the employer, when it supplies a service provider’s details to potential clients, and section 15A can also treat it as employing the person who does the work where a matched provider goes on to contract with a client.

Operators should test their responsibilities against how the platform actually works, including how service providers are registered, matched with customers and allowed to take on work. The operator establishes its statutory excuse through the prescribed article 5B requirements, starting with a written statement in place before the work or service starts, and Home Office guidance does not require it to carry out the prescribed check on each service provider itself.

Describing the platform as an intermediary does not take it outside the regime. An ordinary online directory or advertising service, on the other hand, should be measured against the statutory criteria before it is treated as a matching service.

 

5. Businesses Using Outsourced Recruitment or Checking Services

 

Businesses using outsourced recruitment or checking services keep their statutory responsibility, whatever administrative tasks the provider carries out. Home Office guidance allows checks to be delegated only where the person carrying them out is acting under the employer’s control and direction, and responsibility for ensuring that the check is done correctly stays with the employer.

The guidance also states that, outside a check by a registered RtW DVSP, an employer cannot establish a statutory excuse by relying on a check carried out independently by an outside party. Digital verification services do not need to be bought directly from a registered RtW DVSP. Where an RtW DVSP is used, the employer remains responsible for ensuring that the check meets the prescribed requirements.

Employers must also take reasonable and proportionate steps at the time of the check to confirm that the person being checked is the person who will do the work. Failing to do so leaves the employer without a statutory excuse. Where a third party runs the checking process, the employer should keep the evidence and maintain oversight of how the process works.

 

6. Extended Liability Under Section 15A

 

Extended liability under section 15A of the 2006 Act allows a civil penalty to reach organisations that have contracted to provide or arrange work or services and have subcontracted it, together with online matching services in the circumstances described in Section B. Section A sets out how the deeming provision works.

Section 15A sets the statutory exposure, and Home Office guidance describes how the Home Office intends to enforce it. Liability will ordinarily remain with the direct employer. Where the direct employer cannot be identified and the prescribed requirements have not been met, the Home Office may pursue another organisation in the chain. The guidance adds that the Home Office would not normally expect to issue a civil penalty notice to more than one employer for the same worker.

Potential exposure is different from automatic liability. A business needs to establish whether its arrangement falls within section 15A and, if it does, which statutory excuse is available. The prescribed requirements are set out in article 5B of the Immigration (Restrictions on Employment) Order 2007 (the 2007 Order), inserted by SI 2026/700. They fall into three groups: a written statement of prescribed contractual terms for contractual chains and online matching services, controls on substitution and identity verification systems. Each arrangement needs to be matched to the requirements that apply to it.

 

7. Establishing a Statutory Excuse Against Extended Liability

 

The statutory excuse against extended liability depends on the prescribed requirements in article 5B of the 2007 Order, as amended by the Immigration (Restrictions on Employment and Residential Accommodation) (Prescribed Requirements and Codes of Practice) (Amendment) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/700). Those requirements are read alongside the definitions in section 14A and the deeming provision in section 15A of the 2006 Act.

Home Office guidance states that a written statement is mandatory to establish a statutory excuse and that it must be in place before the work or service commences. General assurances that a supplier complies with immigration law, and indemnities against illegal working penalties, cannot stand in for it.

Evidence matters as much as the terms. The guidance gives no single minimum evidential package, but lists examples such as copies of the contractual terms, audit records and assurance information received from suppliers. For substitution, it refers to records identifying the individual who carried out the work and the period concerned.

For a fuller treatment of how the excuse operates, see Right to Work statutory excuse and Right to Work check requirements.

 

8. Prescribed Contractual Safeguards Under Article 5B(2)

 

The prescribed contractual safeguards under article 5B(2) of the 2007 Order apply to contractual chains and online matching services. The legislation sets out six terms that the written statement must require, which Home Office guidance groups under five headings, alongside a separate requirement for identity verification systems.

1. Compliance With Prescribed Right to Work Requirements

The written statement must require the other employer or service provider to carry out prescribed Right to Work checks. A general promise to comply with all applicable laws does not meet that requirement.

2. Restrictions on Further Subcontracting

The other party must not subcontract further without prior written consent, and any permitted subcontract must carry equivalent Right to Work obligations. Without that control, a business can lose sight of who is doing the work and who has checked them.

3. Contractual Audit Rights

The written statement must allow audits of the other party’s compliance with prescribed Right to Work checks. An audit clause is only useful if it is exercised, so the business should settle what it will ask for and how it will deal with any gaps found. The frequency of audits is not prescribed.

4. Enforcement Provisions for Illegal Working

The written statement must allow enforcement action, such as suspension or termination of the contract, where illegal working is identified and the other party has no statutory excuse. These enforcement rights are distinct from an indemnity, which allocates financial risk between the parties without giving a statutory excuse. Businesses should also have an internal route for escalating suspected illegal working and deciding whether the individual may start or continue the work.

5. Enforcement Provisions in the Contract With the Individual

The written statement must also require the other party to include, in its own contract with the individual doing the work, enforcement provisions that apply where it knows or has reasonable cause to believe the individual is committing the offence of illegal working under section 24B of the Immigration Act 1971. Those provisions may include suspension or termination of the contract.

6. Cooperation With Home Office Investigations

The other party must co-operate with any Home Office investigation, including by providing details of the contract chain and each party involved. Confidentiality clauses should be drafted so that they do not obstruct that obligation.

Continuing Identity Verification Controls

Identity verification controls are a separate requirement from the contractual terms. Proportionate systems must ensure that the person doing the work is the person whose Right to Work was checked, and the guidance gives examples such as ID cards, facial recognition and biometric systems. The Home Office recommends that re-verification happens at least once in any 24-hour period or shift of work. A supplier’s completed check does not answer the identity question on its own, since the risk being controlled is one person being checked while another turns up to work.

Contractual Safeguards and Operational Compliance

The contractual and identity requirements work together. Prescribed terms on paper do not secure the excuse if the practical systems are missing, and good operational checks do not make up for a written statement that lacks a prescribed term. Where a business relies on a supplier’s assurances, it should take reasonable steps to satisfy itself that those assurances are reliable.

 

9. Substitution Requirements Under Article 5B(4)

 

Substitution requirements under article 5B(4) of the 2007 Order apply where a contract allows another individual to do the work in place of the person originally engaged. They operate separately from the article 5B(2) safeguards, and Home Office guidance requires the processes to be in place before work starts.

Checks on the Original Individual and Substitute

A prescribed Right to Work check must be carried out on any substitute. Responsibility for that check cannot be delegated to the individuals doing the work, including where they are described as self-employed.

Checks Before the Substitute Commences Work

No individual may work as a substitute before their Right to Work has been verified. Procedures need to hold firm where substitutions happen at short notice, so a confirmation from the original contractor that substitution is permitted is not enough to let an unchecked person start.

Required Contractual Enforcement Provisions

The contract must make provision for cases where a substitute is known or reasonably suspected to be working illegally, including where a check has not been completed. The guidance gives suspension or termination of the contract as examples.

Effective Identity Controls

Identity controls must ensure that the worker and any registered substitute remain the individuals whose Right to Work was checked. Procedures should cover how substitutes are identified, how changes are notified and how suspected impersonation is investigated.

Applying the Correct Statutory Requirements

A business should first establish whether article 5B(2), article 5B(4) or both apply, then test the requirements against the actual contract. A substitution clause does not by itself decide the statutory category, and an unrestricted right of substitution does not by itself take an arrangement outside the expanded regime.

 

10. Commercial Indemnities and Statutory Safeguards

 

Commercial indemnities and statutory safeguards do different jobs. An indemnity from a supplier can give the end user a contractual remedy if the supplier breaches its obligations, but it does not stop the Home Office imposing a civil penalty on a business that is liable in its own right and cannot establish a statutory excuse.

A warranty that all personnel have permission to work is similarly no substitute for the prescribed requirements on checks, subcontracting, auditing and identity verification. Commercial protections can sit alongside those requirements but cannot replace them.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section F: When Does the Obligation to Carry Out a Right to Work Check Arise?

 

The obligation to carry out a Right to Work check arises before the individual starts work, and the exact timing depends on the statutory category of engagement. For conventional employment, the prescribed check should be completed before employment begins if the employer wants the statutory excuse. For arrangements brought in on 1 October 2026, businesses also need to establish when the contractual arrangement was entered into and when the checking or statutory excuse requirements must be met.

 

1. Before Employment Begins

 

Employers should complete every step of the prescribed check before the individual starts employment. Home Office guidance does not provide for a later check to create a statutory excuse for an earlier period of illegal working, so the check belongs in recruitment and onboarding.

Where the individual’s permission is time-limited, the employer should also note when a follow-up check will fall due.

The detailed checking methods and evidence requirements are covered in how to conduct a Right to Work check.

 

2. Before Work Under a Qualifying Contract Commences

 

Work under a worker’s contract or an individual sub-contractor arrangement also needs the prescribed check before the individual begins. Where extended liability applies, the written statement must be in place before the work or service commences.

Contractual safeguards cannot be relied on if they are added only after the work has started, so the engagement should be assessed at the contracting and onboarding stages.

 

3. Existing Engagements and Transitional Compliance

 

Existing engagements need to be assessed against the expanded regime from 1 October 2026, which is not intended to operate retrospectively. The Home Office describes the test in two ways. The Code of practice on preventing illegal working: Right to Work Scheme for employers states that a civil penalty for the new arrangements, and extended liability under section 15A, applies only where the employment commenced on or after 1 October 2026, and the scope section of the Employer’s guide uses the same commencement wording for worker’s contracts and individual sub-contractors. The guide’s answers on transitional arrangements state instead that the relevant date is when the contractual arrangement is entered into, not when the work starts or continues.

On that transitional approach, an arrangement entered into before 1 October 2026 is not brought within scope solely because work or services continue afterwards. A renewal, extension or variation should not be assumed either to bring an arrangement within scope or to keep it outside. The organisation needs to consider whether the change creates a new arrangement from 1 October 2026, judged by its legal and contractual effect.

The guide also states that there is no general grace period. Obligations that already applied to conventional employment are unchanged.

Businesses should record the arrangements they have assessed, the basis on which responsibilities were allocated and the procedures adopted. Where a contract was signed before 1 October 2026 but the work began afterwards, the commencement wording and the entered-into wording point in different directions. The code of practice is the statutory code issued under section 19 of the 2006 Act, so the safer course is to treat the engagement as within the expanded regime and complete the prescribed checks or safeguards before the work starts. That approach costs little if the guide’s reading prevails and avoids relying on the contract date if a civil penalty is ever in issue.

 

4. Repeat Checks and Time-Limited Immigration Permission

 

Repeat checks depend on the individual’s status. Some people have a continuing, unrestricted Right to Work in the UK, while others have permission that expires or carries conditions.

Where the statutory excuse requires a follow-up check, the employer or engaging organisation should complete it within the prescribed timeframe. A check at the start of an engagement does not give continuing protection where the individual’s permission is time-limited. The requirements depend on the checking method, the individual’s immigration status and the statutory provisions.

For further guidance, see follow-up Right to Work checks.

 

5. Pending Immigration Applications and the Employer Checking Service

 

Pending immigration applications affect whether an individual can keep working after their permission expires. Where the individual made a valid application to extend or vary their permission before it expired, their previous permission continues on the same conditions while the application, and any administrative review or appeal, is pending. Applicants with a valid EU Settlement Scheme application have a Right to Work until the application is finally determined, including any administrative review or appeal.

Where a share code is available, the Home Office online service can be used, and for an in-time application it gives the employer a statutory excuse for six months, with a follow-up check needed on any later application. Where it is not, the Home Office Employer Checking Service (ECS) can verify the position. A Positive Verification Notice (PVN) gives the employer a statutory excuse for six months from the date specified in the notice, and a follow-up check must be completed before that excuse expires.

A 28-day continuation is available in one situation. Where the employer carried out a manual check using List B Group 1 documents, the statutory excuse continues for up to 28 days after the worker’s permission expires if the employer is reasonably satisfied that the worker made an application or appeal to the Home Office on or before that date. During those 28 days the employer must obtain a PVN from the ECS or carry out a Home Office online check, and a Negative Verification Notice ends the excuse. Long-term residents who have lived lawfully in the UK since before 1988 follow a different route, and the employer establishes a statutory excuse only by contacting the ECS and receiving a PVN. Evidence of an application alone does not establish a statutory excuse.

For further information, see Right to Work while a visa application is pending and Employer Checking Service checks.

 

6. Changes to Working Arrangements

 

Changes to a working arrangement can alter the checking position. Examples include a worker moving from employment to a contractor arrangement, a supplier bringing in more subcontractors, an individual being replaced by a substitute or a material change to the contractual structure.

A check or contractual safeguard set up for one arrangement may not meet the requirements of a materially different one. Where a new arrangement is created, the organisation should consider whether the expanded requirements apply and whether the prescribed checks or safeguards must be completed before work begins.

TUPE transfers have their own rules. Where a relevant transfer takes place, the incoming employer is treated as having carried out the checks the outgoing employer made, but only if those checks were done correctly. The Home Office advises a fresh Right to Work check on transferring staff and allows a grace period of 60 calendar days from the date of the transfer to complete it. There is no grace period for any later follow-up checks.

These assessments should be documented as part of the organisation’s wider workforce compliance procedures.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section G: Employer Scope and Responsibility Matrix

 

The employer scope and responsibility matrix below summarises how the statutory Right to Work regime may apply to common working arrangements and which organisations should assess their checking responsibilities. It separates direct checking responsibility from potential extended civil penalty liability under section 15A of the 2006 Act.

The matrix is a starting point for assessment. The actual contractual arrangements and the statutory provisions decide the position in each case.

 

1. Right to Work Checking Responsibility by Working Arrangement

 

Working Arrangement Statutory Checking Position Responsibility and Statutory Excuse Considerations
Permanent employee Prescribed Right to Work check required for the employer to establish the statutory excuse. The direct employer carries out the check before employment begins.
Temporary, casual or fixed-term employee Prescribed check required wherever a contract of employment exists. The direct employer is responsible, however short or infrequent the work.
Individual under a worker’s contract Within the expanded regime where the section 14A definition is met. The engaging party carries out the check. Other organisations need to consider section 15A only where they have contracted to supply the work onward.
Independent professional supplying services to a client or customer Outside the worker’s contract definition where the client or customer exception applies. The actual relationship must be assessed, including whether another statutory provision applies. A label or tax status does not decide it.
Individual sub-contractor Within the expanded regime where the statutory definition is met. The engaging party carries out the check. Parties further up the chain that have contracted to provide the work may face extended liability.
Agency-supplied worker Depends on whether the agency engages and supplies the worker or the end user engages them directly. An agency that engages and supplies the worker is responsible for the check, and the hirer is not expected to duplicate it routinely. A hirer that uses the labour to deliver services it has contracted to provide to a third party should consider section 15A.
End user buying work or services for its own internal operations Extended liability does not apply. The end user remains responsible for anyone it employs or engages directly under a covered arrangement.
Service provider matched through an online matching service Within the expanded regime where the service supplies the provider’s details to clients or customers. The operator is the employer under section 14A and, where a matched provider contracts with a client, can face extended liability under section 15A. Its statutory excuse comes through the written statement and the other article 5B requirements.
Substitute performing subcontracted work Covered by the article 5B(4) substitution requirements where the contract permits substitution. A prescribed check is needed on the substitute before they start, and responsibility cannot be delegated to the individuals doing the work.
Genuine volunteer May fall outside the statutory regime where no covered contractual relationship exists. The organisation should assess the substance of the arrangement and any immigration conditions restricting the activity.
Unpaid intern or trial worker Depends on whether the arrangement falls within a covered statutory category. The organisation should assess the work actually done and any contractual obligations before the activity begins.
Director who is also an employee Prescribed checking requirements apply to the employment relationship. The employing company is responsible for the check.
Non-executive director acting solely as an officeholder May fall outside the statutory checking categories where no covered contractual arrangement exists. The company should assess the individual’s actual role, contractual position and any immigration restrictions.
Sponsored migrant worker Statutory requirements apply where the employment or engagement falls within the regime. Sponsor duties apply whatever the working arrangement. The employer or engaging organisation carries out the prescribed check. The sponsor must obtain and retain evidence of that check or carry out its own.
Individual working entirely overseas Work performed wholly overseas is outside the scheme, even where a UK organisation engages the individual. The organisation should assess any UK activity separately and meet the immigration requirements of the country where the work takes place.

 

2. Interpreting the Responsibility Matrix

 

The responsibility matrix separates the organisation that engages an individual directly from organisations exposed to liability through a contractual chain or a matching service. Extended liability makes a penalty possible, not certain, and the business can still establish a statutory excuse by meeting the article 5B requirements that fit its arrangement.

Contractual chains and matching services rely on the written statement and identity verification systems, while substitution arrangements have their own requirements. Supplier assurances do not meet either set. No party needs to repeat every check made elsewhere in the chain, but each needs to know which requirements apply to it before deciding what it must do.

 

3. Why More Than One Organisation May Have Responsibilities

 

More than one organisation can have responsibilities for the same individual. A labour provider may engage the worker directly while a principal contractor that has subcontracted the work faces extended liability under section 15A. A licensed sponsor keeps its record-keeping duties even where another organisation carries out the statutory check under an arrangement the sponsorship rules permit.

Identifying one responsible organisation does not clear the others. Each party’s responsibilities should be considered and documented separately, and where agencies or subcontractors are involved, the contractual allocation should be backed by verification procedures and records.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section H: Common Employer Mistakes When Determining Who Needs a Right to Work Check

 

Common employer mistakes when determining who needs a Right to Work check usually come from misreading the scope of the regime or misallocating responsibility. The changes of 1 October 2026 make it more likely that arrangements once treated as outside the civil penalty framework now need review.

 

1. Assuming Only Foreign Nationals Need Checks

 

Checking only people who seem to be foreign nationals is one of the most common errors. Prescribed checks should be carried out consistently across the workforce, British and Irish citizens included. Selective checking creates discrimination risk and can leave the employer without the evidence it needs for a statutory excuse.

See discrimination and Right to Work checks.

 

2. Assuming Self-Employed Contractors Are Automatically Exempt

 

Treating self-employed contractors as automatically exempt overlooks section 14A, which brings worker’s contracts and individual sub-contractors within the regime. The questions are whether the individual must do the work personally, whether the client or customer exception applies and whether the subcontracting provisions are engaged. Tax status, invoicing and contractual labels are not conclusive.

 

3. Assuming an Agency Is Always Solely Responsible

 

Assuming the agency is always solely responsible is safe only where the agency engages and supplies the worker and the hirer uses the labour for its own operations. A hirer that engages the individual directly has its own checking responsibility. A hirer that has contracted to provide services to a third party and uses agency labour to deliver them may face extended liability and will need a written statement and identity controls. A general assurance from the agency does not meet the prescribed requirements.

 

4. Relying on Contractual Indemnities Instead of Statutory Safeguards

 

Relying on indemnities instead of statutory safeguards leaves a business exposed. An indemnity or warranty can shift financial risk between the parties but does not establish a statutory excuse against a Home Office civil penalty. Where article 5B applies, the prescribed contractual and operational requirements must be met.

For further guidance, see Right to Work statutory excuse.

 

5. Failing to Control Substitution Arrangements

 

Uncontrolled substitution creates a gap whenever the person originally checked is replaced by someone else. Where the substitution requirements apply, every substitute needs a prescribed check before starting work, and responsibility for that check cannot be delegated to the individuals doing the work. Identity controls are needed to stop impersonation and unauthorised substitution.

 

6. Failing to Identify the Full Contractual Chain

 

Failing to identify the full contractual chain is a risk wherever a supplier delivers work through several layers of subcontracting. Where section 15A applies, having no direct contract with the individual does not prevent extended liability. The business should establish which parties are involved, who engages the individual and which safeguards apply, and make sure the written statement covers further subcontracting, audit rights and co-operation with Home Office investigations.

 

7. Treating a Previous Right to Work Check as Permanently Sufficient

 

Treating an earlier check as permanently sufficient misses two points. A check made for a previous employer or a different arrangement does not satisfy the requirements of a new engagement, and where permission is time-limited the statutory excuse may depend on a follow-up check.

 

8. Assuming All Pre-October 2026 Contracts Are Covered

 

Assuming that every contract made before October 2026 is now covered overstates the reach of the expanded regime, which is not intended to apply retrospectively. The transitional answers in the Employer’s guide treat the relevant date as when the contractual arrangement was entered into, and an arrangement is not brought within scope solely because work continues after 1 October 2026. The code of practice, and the scope section of the guide, refer instead to employment that commenced on or after that date, so both tests should be considered.

Renewals, extensions and variations should be assessed on their legal and contractual effect to decide whether they create a new arrangement on or after 1 October 2026, whatever the parties call them. Where a contract was signed before that date and the work started afterwards, the safer course is to treat the engagement as covered and complete the prescribed checks or safeguards before work begins.

 

9. Overlooking Sponsor Licence Obligations

 

Overlooking sponsor licence obligations is a separate risk for licensed sponsors. Where a sponsored worker is employed or engaged by another organisation under an arrangement the sponsorship rules permit, that organisation is normally responsible for the check, but the sponsor must still obtain and retain evidence of it or carry out its own. Compliance with one regime does not establish compliance with the other.

See sponsor compliance.

 

10. Failing to Record the Basis for Checking Decisions

 

Failing to record the basis for checking decisions makes it hard to show, during a Home Office investigation, that obligations were properly assessed. Businesses should be able to explain why an individual or arrangement was treated as inside or outside the regime. Where responsibilities are shared or prescribed safeguards are relied on, the business should keep evidence of the contractual arrangements and the procedures it operates.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section I: How Employers Can Establish Their Right to Work Checking Scope

 

Employers can establish their Right to Work checking scope through a structured review that identifies which individuals need checks and which organisations are responsible for them. The review should cover conventional employment, the arrangements brought in on 1 October 2026 and any extended liability through contractual chains or matching services, and it should keep the statutory checking requirements apart from wider immigration and sponsor licence duties.

 

1. Identify Every Category of Working Arrangement

 

Every route through which people do work or provide services for the organisation should be listed. That includes permanent and temporary employment, casual work, agency labour, consultancy, individual sub-contractors and services delivered through online platforms, whether the individuals are engaged directly or supplied by another organisation.

Payroll records give only part of the picture, because many people within the expanded regime never appear on the organisation’s payroll.

 

2. Examine the Actual Contractual Relationship

 

Each category then needs to be tested against the statutory definitions. The organisation should establish whether there is a contract of employment, a worker’s contract or an individual sub-contractor arrangement and, where the individual runs an independent profession or business, whether the client or customer exception applies. The assessment should follow the substance of the relationship and treat contractual labels as a starting point only.

 

3. Map the Contractual Chain

 

Work supplied or arranged through another business needs a map of every party in the chain, which may include the end user, a principal contractor, a labour provider, one or more subcontractors and the individual doing the work.

The map should show which party engages the individual directly and where each party sits. A party that has contracted to provide the work or services to someone else and subcontracted it may face extended liability under section 15A. A party buying the work for its own internal operations does not. The map should also record whether further subcontracting is permitted and how new parties are brought in.

 

4. Identify the Responsible Organisation

 

The responsible organisation for each arrangement follows from the map. The business should record which party engages the individual directly, which other parties may be treated as employers and whether a statutory excuse is available to each of them.

Where the business relies on prescribed contractual safeguards, the written statement must be in place before the work begins and the operational controls must be working, including identity verification, substitute checks and a process for responding to suspected illegal working. The allocation should name who carries out checks, who verifies the identity of people attending work and who holds the evidence. Where more than one organisation has responsibilities, each party’s obligations should be set out separately.

 

5. Establish the Applicable Checking or Statutory Excuse Procedure

 

The checking or statutory excuse procedure depends on the category and the responsible organisation. Direct employment will ordinarily need the prescribed Right to Work check before employment begins. Worker’s contracts and individual sub-contractor arrangements need the prescribed check before the work starts. Extended liability calls for the article 5B safeguards that fit the arrangement, whether the written statement and identity systems or the substitution controls.

The procedure should be measured against the legislation and current Home Office guidance, and commercial assurances should not be mistaken for the prescribed conditions.

For guidance on checking methods, see how to conduct a Right to Work check.

 

6. Integrate Checks Into Recruitment and Procurement

 

Checking scope belongs in recruitment and procurement, where it can be settled before anyone starts work. For employees, the procedure sits within recruitment and onboarding. For contractors and labour suppliers, it sits within procurement, supplier appointment and contract management.

The business should fix when contractual safeguards must be agreed, when checks must be completed and how the evidence will reach it. Where substitution is permitted, procedures should stop an unchecked substitute from starting work. Staff responsible for recruitment, procurement and operational supervision each need to know their part in the process.

 

7. Document Decisions and Maintain Oversight

 

Documented decisions allow a business to show how it assessed and allocated checking responsibilities. Where extended liability safeguards are relied on, the records should go beyond the supplier agreement and show the prescribed terms in place and the practical controls in operation, such as identity verification records, substitute checks, supplier due diligence and the action taken when discrepancies or suspected illegal working came to light.

A written policy or a contractual clause does not replace the procedures the statutory excuse requires. Arrangements should be reviewed periodically, particularly when suppliers change, new subcontractors are brought in or the individuals doing the work change. A renewal, extension or variation should prompt a fresh look at whether the expanded regime now applies, and sponsored workers need separate oversight of the sponsor licence duties.

For further guidance on reviewing compliance procedures, see Right to Work audits.

 

 

Back to top

 

Section J: How DavidsonMorris Can Help

 

DavidsonMorris advises employers and other organisations on who needs a Right to Work check where the workforce combines employees, contractors, agency labour, subcontractors and outsourced services. Our immigration solicitors advise on Right to Work checking obligations, statutory excuses, workforce compliance systems and sponsor licence requirements, and can help businesses assess their working arrangements, find compliance gaps and put suitable procedures in place.

 

1. Reviewing Workforce and Contractor Arrangements

 

We review the contracts through which individuals work for an organisation, including employment contracts, worker agreements, consultancy arrangements, agency labour and subcontracting structures. That includes advising on whether arrangements fall within the expanded statutory definitions, whether the client or customer exception applies and how renewals, extensions and variations affect arrangements entered into before 1 October 2026.

 

2. Assessing Direct and Extended Liability

 

We help businesses identify which organisations carry direct checking responsibility and whether section 15A exposes them to extended liability. Where a contractual chain is involved, we review the relationships between end users, principal contractors, labour providers and subcontractors and advise on the statutory excuse and the safeguards it requires.

 

3. Reviewing Contractual Safeguards

 

We advise on written statements intended to meet the prescribed requirements in article 5B of the 2007 Order, covering Right to Work checks, further subcontracting, audit rights, enforcement and co-operation with Home Office investigations. We also advise on how those requirements interact with warranties, indemnities and other commercial protections.

 

4. Developing Right to Work Compliance Procedures

 

We help organisations develop or review internal procedures for deciding checking scope, allocating responsibilities and keeping compliance records. That work covers agency workers, contractors, substitutes and complex labour supply arrangements, together with identity verification controls, escalation procedures and the handling of suspected illegal working.

 

5. Right to Work Audits and Home Office Investigations

 

DavidsonMorris reviews Right to Work compliance arrangements to identify weaknesses before they lead to enforcement action. Where an organisation faces a Home Office investigation or a civil penalty concern, we advise on the statutory provisions, the availability of a statutory excuse and the response.

For more information, see Right to Work audits.

 

6. Sponsor Licence Compliance

 

For licensed sponsors, we advise on how Right to Work requirements interact with sponsor duties, including arrangements where sponsored workers are engaged by other organisations, record-keeping and changes to working arrangements. We also carry out sponsor compliance reviews and support sponsors facing Home Office scrutiny.

For advice on your organisation’s Right to Work checking responsibilities, contact DavidsonMorris.

 

Back to top

 

Section K: Frequently Asked Questions About Who Needs a Right to Work Check

 

Does every employee need a Right to Work check?

Every employee needs a Right to Work check before employment begins if the employer wants a statutory excuse against a civil penalty, whatever the employee’s nationality. The requirement covers British and Irish citizens as well as people who need immigration permission, and the scheme applies to people aged 16 or over. The checking method depends on the individual’s circumstances, and the same process should be used for everyone to avoid discrimination.

 

Do British citizens need Right to Work checks?

British citizens need a Right to Work check before employment begins, even though they generally have an unrestricted Right to Work in the UK. A manual check can use a British passport, current or expired, or a UK birth or adoption certificate together with an official document showing the person’s name and permanent National Insurance number. A registered RtW DVSP can check a British passport digitally. A name, address, National Insurance number or work history does not on its own give the employer a statutory excuse.

 

Do self-employed contractors need Right to Work checks?

Self-employed contractors may need a Right to Work check, because self-employed status does not by itself take an individual outside the regime. Since 1 October 2026 the scheme has covered worker’s contracts and individual sub-contractors. Genuine independent businesses fall outside it where the engaging party is a client or customer of the individual’s own profession or business, and Home Office guidance gives the examples of a self-employed plumber and a designer working through a personal service company. The actual relationship, including any obligation to do the work personally, decides the position.

See Right to Work checks for contractors.

 

Who is responsible for checking agency workers?

Agency workers are checked by the agency where it engages and supplies them, and Home Office guidance states that the hirer is not expected to duplicate those checks routinely. An end user that engages the individual directly carries its own checking responsibility. Extended liability does not apply to an end user buying work or services for its own internal operations. A business that uses agency labour to deliver services it has contracted to provide to a third party may face extended liability and will need a written statement with the agency.

See Right to Work checks for agency workers.

 

Do volunteers need Right to Work checks?

Genuine volunteers can fall outside the Right to Work checking regime where they give their time freely, with no contract and no pay beyond limited expenses. Home Office guidance distinguishes volunteers from voluntary workers, who are under a contractual obligation to perform work and can only be used by certain organisations. Organisations should look at the substance of the arrangement and check that any immigration conditions allow the activity, since other unpaid work may still need permission.

 

Do employers need to check temporary and casual workers?

Temporary and casual workers need Right to Work checks in the same way as permanent staff where they have a contract of employment, however short or irregular the work. Where they are not employees, the organisation should assess whether the arrangement is a worker’s contract or another covered category. The check should be completed before the work begins.

 

Does a business need to check a substitute worker?

A substitute worker needs a prescribed Right to Work check before starting work where the substitution requirements in article 5B(4) of the 2007 Order apply. Responsibility for that check cannot be delegated to the individuals doing the work. The contract must provide for cases where a substitute is known or reasonably suspected to be working illegally, and identity controls must ensure that the person working is the person who was checked. A contractual right of substitution does not remove the Right to Work requirements.

 

Can an employer rely on a Right to Work check carried out by another organisation?

Relying on a Right to Work check carried out by another organisation does not normally give an employer its own statutory excuse. Home Office guidance allows checks to be delegated to people acting under the employer’s control and direction, but an employer cannot rely on a check carried out independently by an outside party unless it is a check by a registered RtW DVSP. Extended liability has its own route through the prescribed written statement and identity controls, and supplier assurances do not replace them. Licensed sponsors whose sponsored worker is engaged by another organisation must obtain and retain evidence of that organisation’s check or carry out their own.

See Right to Work statutory excuse.

 

Can a business be fined for illegal workers engaged by a subcontractor?

A business can be fined for illegal workers engaged by a subcontractor where it has contracted to provide the work or services and subcontracted them, because section 15A treats it as employing anyone who personally does the work. Liability ordinarily stays with the direct employer, but the Home Office may pursue another organisation in the chain where the direct employer cannot be identified and the prescribed requirements have not been met. The civil penalty calculation starts at £45,000 per illegal worker for a first breach and £60,000 for a repeat breach within three years, before any reductions. A business buying services for its own internal operations is outside extended liability. For a business that is exposed, a written statement in place before work starts, backed by effective identity verification, is the route to a statutory excuse.

 

Do the October 2026 Right to Work changes apply to existing contracts?

The October 2026 Right to Work changes are not intended to apply retrospectively. The transitional answers in the Employer’s guide treat the relevant date as the date the contractual arrangement was entered into, so an arrangement made before 1 October 2026 is not brought within scope solely because work continues afterwards. The code of practice, and the scope section of the guide, refer instead to employment that commenced on or after 1 October 2026, so both tests should be considered. Where a contract was signed before that date and the work started afterwards, the safer course is to treat the engagement as covered and complete the prescribed checks or safeguards before work begins. A renewal, extension or variation should be assessed on its legal and contractual effect to decide whether it creates a new arrangement. Obligations that already applied to employees are unchanged.

 

Do directors and company owners need Right to Work checks?

Directors and company owners need a Right to Work check where they are employed under a contract of employment or engaged under a worker’s contract or another covered arrangement. A director acting solely as an officeholder, with no covered contract, may fall outside the checking regime. Companies should also confirm that any director subject to immigration control has permission for the activities they will carry out.

 

Does a Right to Work check need to be repeated?

Repeating a Right to Work check depends on the individual’s immigration status and the checking method used. Where the individual has a continuing Right to Work and the initial check was carried out correctly, a follow-up check may not be required. Where permission is time-limited, a follow-up check is needed to keep the statutory excuse, and a check through the online service for an in-time application, or a Positive Verification Notice, gives a six-month excuse. A new engagement or a materially different arrangement should prompt a fresh look at the checking position.

See follow-up Right to Work checks.

 

Back to top

 

Section L: Conclusion

 

Deciding who needs a Right to Work check now involves more than identifying conventional employees. Since 1 October 2026 the statutory framework has also covered worker’s contracts, individual sub-contractors and online matching services, and section 15A can extend liability to businesses that have contracted to provide work or services and subcontracted them.

Three questions run through every assessment: whether the individual falls within a covered category, which organisation has direct checking responsibility and whether any other organisation faces extended liability. They matter most where work is arranged through agencies, contractors, subcontractors or digital platforms, and they have different answers for a business buying services for its own operations and a business supplying services onward to a client.

Supplier assurances, indemnities and the absence of a direct employment relationship do not remove statutory responsibility. Where extended liability applies, the business needs the prescribed written statement, identity verification and, where relevant, substitution controls in place before the work begins. The timing of each contract also matters, particularly for arrangements entered into before 1 October 2026 and later renewed, extended or varied. Licensed sponsors have separate duties to meet alongside the statutory scheme.

A structured review of workforce arrangements, checking responsibilities and supporting records allows organisations to deal with gaps before anyone starts work and before a Home Office investigation brings them to light.

DavidsonMorris advises employers on Right to Work compliance, statutory excuses, contractor and labour supply arrangements, sponsor licence obligations and responses to Home Office investigations. For advice on your organisation’s obligations, contact our immigration solicitors.

 

Back to top

 

Section M: Glossary

 

Term Meaning
Right to Work Check

A Right to Work check is a prescribed check of an individual’s entitlement to do the work in question in the UK, carried out manually, through the Home Office online service, through a registered RtW DVSP or with the Employer Checking Service. A correct check made at the right time gives the employer a statutory excuse against a civil penalty.

Statutory Excuse

A statutory excuse protects an organisation from a civil penalty for illegal working where it has met the prescribed requirements. For direct engagements it comes from a prescribed check before work begins. For extended liability it depends on the article 5B safeguards that apply to the arrangement.

Direct Employer

The direct employer is the organisation in the direct contractual relationship with the individual doing the work, whether under a contract of employment, a worker’s contract or another covered arrangement. Liability for illegal working ordinarily stays with the direct employer.

Worker’s Contract

A worker’s contract is a contract, other than a contract of service or apprenticeship, under which an individual undertakes to do work or services personally for a party that is not a client or customer of the individual’s own profession or business. Section 14A of the 2006 Act brings it within the illegal working provisions.

Individual Subcontractor

An individual sub-contractor is an individual who contracts with a business to provide work or services that the business has itself contracted to provide to a third party. Individual sub-contractors have been within the Right to Work scheme since 1 October 2026.

Client or Customer Exception

The client or customer exception in section 14A takes an arrangement outside the worker’s contract definition where the engaging party is a client or customer of a profession or business undertaking carried on by the individual. Whether it applies depends on the actual relationship.

Extended Liability

Extended liability under section 15A of the 2006 Act treats a business that has contracted to provide or arrange work or services, and subcontracted them, as employing anyone who personally does the work. It can also apply to an online matching service. It does not apply to an end user buying work or services for its own internal operations.

Contractual Chain

A contractual chain is the series of contracts through which work or services are provided or arranged, which may involve an end user, a principal contractor, labour providers, subcontractors and the individual doing the work.

Online Matching Service

An online matching service is a register or platform operated as a business that matches service providers with clients or customers. It falls within section 14A, which treats the operator as the employer, when it supplies a service provider’s details to potential clients, and section 15A can also treat it as employing the person who does the work where a matched provider contracts with a client. Its statutory excuse comes through the article 5B requirements, starting with a written statement.

Prescribed Contractual Safeguards

The prescribed contractual safeguards are the six terms a written statement must require to give a statutory excuse against extended liability: carrying out prescribed checks, no further subcontracting without prior written consent, audits of compliance with prescribed checks, enforcement action against the other party, enforcement provisions in the other party’s contract with the individual where illegal working is known or suspected and co-operation with Home Office investigations.

Identity Verification Controls

Identity verification controls are proportionate systems that ensure the person doing the work is the person whose Right to Work was checked, such as ID cards, facial recognition or biometric systems. The Home Office recommends re-verification at least once in any 24-hour period or shift of work.

Substitution

Substitution is an arrangement under which another individual does the work in place of the person originally engaged. Under article 5B(4) of the 2007 Order, any substitute needs a prescribed check before starting work, and responsibility for that check cannot be delegated to the individuals doing the work.

Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006

The Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 sets up the civil penalty scheme for employing an adult subject to immigration control who has no permission to do the work, and the section 21 criminal offence. Sections 14A and 15A, inserted by section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025, extend it to non-employee arrangements and extended liability.

Immigration (Restrictions on Employment) Order 2007

The Immigration (Restrictions on Employment) Order 2007 is the secondary legislation that prescribes the requirements for a statutory excuse. Article 5B, inserted by SI 2026/700, sets out the written statement, substitution and identity verification requirements for extended liability.

Employer Checking Service

The Employer Checking Service (ECS) is one of the prescribed ways to check Right to Work, used where the online service is not available, for example where an individual has an outstanding application and no share code. A positive result is a Positive Verification Notice.

Positive Verification Notice

A Positive Verification Notice (PVN) is issued by the Employer Checking Service to confirm that an individual has the right to do the work in question. It gives the employer a statutory excuse for six months from the date specified in the notice.

Licensed Sponsor

A licensed sponsor is an organisation authorised by the Home Office to sponsor workers on eligible immigration routes. Sponsors have duties separate from the statutory scheme, including checking and keeping evidence of Right to Work for every worker they sponsor.

Appendix D

Appendix D is the Home Office sponsor guidance on record-keeping duties (version 10/26, valid from 8 October 2026). It requires sponsors to keep evidence of Right to Work checks, including where a sponsored worker is employed or engaged by another organisation.

RtW DVSP

A Right to Work digital verification service provider (RtW DVSP) is a provider on the digital verification services register that can check British and Irish passports digitally, including expired passports up to six months past expiry, and List A and List B documents where they are available digitally.

Written Statement

A written statement is the document setting out the prescribed contractual terms between a business and the other employer or service provider in a chain or matching arrangement. Home Office guidance states that it is mandatory for a statutory excuse against extended liability and must be in place before the work or service commences.

 

Back to top

 

Section N: Related DavidsonMorris Guidance

 

Description URL
Right to Work Checks: Employer Guide. The complete employer guide to Right to Work checks, methods and compliance. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-checks/
Right to Work Check Requirements. The legal requirements for a compliant check, including follow-up checks. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-check-requirements/
Right to Work Statutory Excuse. How a statutory excuse protects employers and what it requires. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-law-employer-obligations/#E
How to Conduct a Right to Work Check. Step-by-step guidance on manual, online and digital checks. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-check/
Right to Work Documents. The List A and List B documents accepted for manual checks. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-documents/
Right to Work Checks for Agency Workers. Checking responsibilities for agencies, labour providers and hirers. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-in-different-working-arrangements/#C
Right to Work Checks for Contractors. Checking contractors, individual sub-contractors and supply chains. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-in-different-working-arrangements/#D
Right to Work Rules for UK Gig Employers. Obligations for online matching services and platform work. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-rules-for-uk-gig-employers/
Follow-Up Right to Work Checks. When repeat checks are needed for time-limited permission. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-check-requirements/#D4
Employer Checking Service Checks. Using the ECS for pending applications and other cases. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/ecs-check/
Discrimination and Right to Work Checks. Applying checks consistently and avoiding unlawful discrimination. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/discrimination-right-to-work-checks/
Right to Work Audits. Reviewing Right to Work compliance across the workforce. https://www.davidsonmorris.com/right-to-work-audit/

 

Back to top

 

Official Sources

 

The legislation and Home Office guidance below set out who needs a Right to Work check, which organisations may be liable for illegal working and what the statutory excuse requires. Employers should refer to the current versions when assessing their responsibilities.

 

Description URL

 

AUTHOR PROFILE

About our expert

Picture of Anne Morris

Anne Morris

Founder and Managing Director Anne Morris is a fully qualified Immigration solicitor and workforce compliance specialist, advising corporates and SMEs on strategic and complex UK immigration and workforce compliance matters. She is recognised by Legal 500 and Chambers, providing Board-level advice on business migration, compliance risk and efficient immigration programme delivery. Anne is also a public speaker, immigration commentator and policy contributor, and regularly delivers training for employers and HR professionals.
Picture of Anne Morris

Anne Morris

Founder and Managing Director Anne Morris is a fully qualified Immigration solicitor and workforce compliance specialist, advising corporates and SMEs on strategic and complex UK immigration and workforce compliance matters. She is recognised by Legal 500 and Chambers, providing Board-level advice on business migration, compliance risk and efficient immigration programme delivery. Anne is also a public speaker, immigration commentator and policy contributor, and regularly delivers training for employers and HR professionals.

DISCOVER

Related articles

uk eu youth mobility scheme
20 November 2026

UK EU Youth Mobility Scheme 2026: Latest Update

Read Article
who needs a right to work check
20 November 2026

Who Needs a Right to Work Check? UK Employer Guide 2026

Read Article
right to work check requirements
20 November 2026

Right to Work Checks: UK Employer Legal Requirements (2026)

Read Article
right to work changes 2026
19 November 2026

UK Right to Work Changes 2026

Read Article

Legal Disclaimer

The matters contained in this article are intended to be for general information purposes only. This article does not constitute legal advice, nor is it a complete or authoritative statement of the law, and should not be treated as such. Whilst every effort is made to ensure that the information is correct at the time of writing, no warranty, express or implied, is given as to its accuracy and no liability is accepted for any error or omission. Before acting on any of the information contained herein, expert legal advice should be sought.

STAY INFORMED

Insights & invitations
into your inbox

Sign up to stay up to date.